Elizabeth
アメリカ合衆国 · カップル · 2026年10月
10.0「Everything was enjoyable and we’d love to stay again!」
+We loved the ease of checking in, the staff was pleasant, and it was easy to find our room.
−Parking was a challenge but we managed and all was well.
Constance
アメリカ合衆国 · カップル · 2026年10月
9.0「Very nice hotel, but not the historical gem I expected, so it seemed overpriced.」
+Large, clean, standard hotel room with comfortable bed, though window view was obstructed by A/C equipment. Excellent housekeeping. Front desk staff friendly and helpful. Beautiful neighborhood.
−Just a hotel room - no historic ambiance. A noisy party on the main floor kept me awake on the 3rd floor. No food available for guests in the evening; no restaurants in walking distance.
tamarabK3909CK
カップル · 2026年7月
10.0「Fun spot to call ‘home’」
+What a fun change from a hotel room! Stayed here as a base of operations for a trip to Pittsburgh. Beautiful historic property!
「An Anniversary to Remember!」
+We are so delighted with our stay at Mansions on Fifth! We got married here last year and came back for our first anniversary, and without us even asking the staff had set out a “Happy Anniversary” card and complimentary prosecco and charcuterie. Such a lovely and thoughtful team, and we hope to come back again in future!
G4434VYsusane
家族旅行 · 2026年4月
8.0「Good night's sleep」
+This is our third stay here while visiting our daughter who goes to Pitt. I love the character and Old World charm. It is a short walk to campus and accessible by bus. The rooms have antique furniture and very comfortable beds. It is not a budget hotel but does offer boxed breakfast to order.
joannasQ8271CK
カップル · 2026年3月
2.0「Avoid」
+Not worth the money. Water doesn’t drain properly from a sink. Charging outlets malfunction. Bring your own water or drink tap. There are no water glasses in the room, no refrigerator. The bedsheets should be replaced as they are grey-ish and look used and unclean.
「The best spot in the burgh!」
+Wonderful place...the house, the welcome, the ambience...all superb!
「Cool older hotel」
+To enjoy the hotel you have to be in the right mindset. It’s an old mansion and everything is quirky, which is also what makes it great. It’s very well take care of for the age and it seems very authentic. I loved all the rich dark wood, fireplaces, paintings, etc… It’s a little inconvenient to get your luggage to the third floor as the elevator stops on two, but again it’s an old mansion, so that didn’t bother us. I didn’t give it 5 stars due to the room description, we stayed in a two room suite. From their website: “Our Deluxe lofts and Suites are both two floor suites with a living room area with a Queen size pull out sofa-bed as well as a King Size bed in the Master bedroom.” The wording very much implies there are two separate private rooms, especially with the “master bedroom” wording. In reality it’s two separate areas that have a small staircase between them. Really just one room on two levels. Most other hotels this would still be a junior suite not a one/two bedroom suite which is typically a separate private bedroom and living area. It’s not much different than their less expensive one room suites with a sleeper sofa, same space just spread across two floors, not any mo
「Terrible customer service at Manions on 5th in Shadyside.」
+Tried to reserve a spot for the Easter Brunch late February, the events person was "Out of the office for an extended time". No one else at the hotel was able to make a simple 2-person reservation. The phone message said to call back in a week, and I did. I got a call back with a time to reserve at about 1:30pm, by the time I called back the next day, I was told the table was taken. So I needed to wait for them for a week, but they couldn't wait a half a day for my response when I already said I wanted to reserve?? The Easter Brunch always fills up, so just waiting for my response would have been no skin off their nose, they simply didn't care. Terrible customer service, will never go to this place again.
「A bona fide mansion」
+Recently enjoyed a one-night stay at the Mansions on Fifth, actually at the next-door Amberson House, not the main mansion. The home is 120 years old but has been well maintained and updated/renovated over the years, of course. It was cozy, quiet and comfortable. My only critique would be the staff itself, which could use a course in professionalism. No one was particularly personable or friendly, although we did not have a great deal of interaction with them. Just a bit off-putting.