Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 200 reviews.
Barbara
United States · Couple · November 2026
8.0“A very lovely view and hotel.”
+A very quiet area with great views of the harbor.
−Slightly inconvenient to restaurants.
Melodina
United States · Couple · November 2026
9.0“Love the view of our room”
+Beautiful location and view
−The cable wasn’t working right and there was still a food in the fridge when we checked in
Daniela
United States · Group of friends · September 2026
10.0+The Zane Grey Pueblo Hotel is a gem on Catalina Island. I cannot believe how convenient it was. There is complimentary golf cart transportation provided by the hotel. They will not only pick you up from your ferry arrival but transport you back and forth to downtown Avalon any time you like from 8am-10pm. The suite we stayed in was absolutely gorgeous, hugeeee, and one of the cleanest rooms I've stayed in. After checkout, the lovely front desk staff ensured that our luggage would be delivered to the ferry port for our departure home. I would highly recommend this hotel!!
Zoe
United States · Group of friends · August 2026
10.0“10/10 would stay again!!! view from room is unmatched on the island!”
+we were shown exceptional hospitality by everyone on property! I was pleasantly surprised to find out about the drivers on call & free breakfast!!
−the other reviews warned me but it could be cleaner…
jimmylS5693DG
Couple · July 2026
10.0“Amazing Hotel With Great Location, Professional Staff, and Beautiful View of Catalina”
+My wife and I stayed here for almost a week and our stay was amazing! Our room was very clean and comfortable with a balcony that had a stunning view of the ocean during the day and a beautiful view of the city lights at night. It was walking distance from Avalon but the hotel provided free shuttles to town and the drivers gave us lots of helpful tips since they are locals. The complimentary breakfast was very nice with a balcony where we could see the city and mountains. All the hotel staff were attentive, professional, and friendly. We will definitely come back here the next time we visit Catalina and highly recommend this wonderful hotel to everyone!
Yang
United States · Family · July 2026
7.0“Overall, despite a few cleanliness issues, we had a great stay and really enjoyed the experience.”
+The view outside the window is spectacular. It’s my favorite part of this place. The staff are all very friendly.
−The room’s cleanliness needs improvement. At first glance, it looked clean, but the floors clearly hadn’t been properly mopped,there was hair in several places. I ended up buying cleaning supplies and mopping the floor twice myself. Also, the quality of the toiletries, including the body wash and toilet paper, was far below what I would expect from a hotel that charges around $1,000 per night. The room could also use an air freshener. It had an unpleasant smell when we first walked in.
christophermX3726NM
Couple · June 2026
10.0“Weekend getaway”
+Really enjoyed our stay at Zane Grey Pueblo. The views overlooking the bay are hard to beat, and being up on the hill gives the property a unique feel. The breakfast was surprisingly good with made-to-order omelets and French toasts. The pool was clean, the property was well kept, and everyone we interacted with was friendly. The highlight for us was the service. We weren’t ready to meet the shuttle driver at the pier, and instead of having us go to him, he went out of his way to drop our luggage off at the restaurant where we were having lunch. Shout out to Kevin for going above and beyond! Would happily stay here again on our next trip to Catalina.
Snyder
United States · Couple · June 2026
8.0“Lovely night with great accommodations.”
+Property was lovely. The historic site is built on the hill, with incredible views of the bay and downtown Avalon.
−It is set outside of town, so if you don’t want to walk up and down the hill, it can be a pain- but there is a golf cart that can pick you up and drop you off by request. The property was a bit sleepy during our weeknight.
Shannon
United States · Couple · June 2026
8.0“Overall good stay. I’d stay again but staff needs to communicate better and clearly in late checkout policy”
+Nice and convenient with the golf cart shuttle. Spacious room!
−I was told two different things about late check out option. Staff should get on the same page about that. At check in the lady said it may be available for an additional 30 minutes at no charge. Then the day of check out when I asked about getting a 30 minute later check out and was told my card would be charged half the price for another nights stay! Needless to say I didn’t do a late check out.
Georgia
United States · Couple · May 2026
10.0“Very nice accommodation with free breakfast option before being shuttled to town in the staff operated golf cart. Picked”
+Historic property above the town noise. Great views and close to Chime tower. Golf carts picked us up from ferry and then when checking out delivered our luggage to ferry drop off so we could explore more without carrying our luggage.
−Price variability was dramatic after our stay because of it being Memorial Day. We purposely stayed on the nights before the weekend to save money. Price doubled for the two nights after check out.