Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 200 reviews.
Diana
United Kingdom · Couple · October 2026
“I suppose value for money under the circumstances.”
+Location good Didn’t realize I booked shared toilet & bathroom Bedroom clean
−Hall & stairs not very inviting kitchen full of guests food & drink Cleanish area
Kathleen
United Kingdom · Family · October 2026
+Liked the location on the bus route into St. Andrews. The double bed was very comfortable. The heating in our room was excellent and nice to have access to a kitchen.
−Shared a bathroom, my choice, which was clean but I didn't like the fact there was no heating. A toilet which was not separate from the bathroom which is important when sharing . No chairs anywhere: bedroom, bathroom or kitchen. No heat in the kitchen.
michael
Canada · Couple · October 2026
“A Good Stay Overall”
+Proximity to St. Andrews. Good value and very friendly, helpful staff
−Only one thing really needs attention. I was in rm 7 across from the pub. The bathroom sink does not have a P-trap? Sewer gases freely flow into the space?? Not sure if this is acceptable by UK building code for a hotel but it should definitely be fixed. I reported the problem to the maid and took my own measures to mitigate the odor.
Valtteri
Finland · Family · October 2026
“It is mostly a Pub and not that much an hotel”
+Convenient location between highlands and Edinburgh. Free parking space.
−There is a pub in the ground level playing music in high volumes. They turned the volume down a bit when asked but it did not much help. I was traveling with my family, but this is not a suitable place for kids. The room was tolerable but I could not rest enough to drive on the next morning because of the loud sounds and pub customers being loud. Toilet had a bad sewage smell.
Dana
Czechia · Couple · October 2026
“Convenient to St. Andrews and a great value for money”
+Ye Olde Hotel is a traditional pub with rooms to rent. We booked the room with a private bathroom and it was spacious and spotlessly clean. It was amusing that the entry is directly off the street. We checked in at the bar, the guy was pleasant and helpful, explaining everything. Bed was very comfortable and the bathroom nice.
−As some noted, the room can be a bit noisy, with its location on an intersection but we still had a comfortable good night sleep, the traffic at night was almost non-existent.
Connell
United Kingdom · Family · October 2026
“Excellent stay and location”
+Staff friendly and welcoming access to other modes of transport ti city centre good location services great for our need for a stay over would come again kind regards susan
−There was one upleasant scene with a female customer hurling accusations toward a family member but passion resolved
Jenny
United Kingdom · Family · October 2026
“Excellent value, handy for St Andrews”
+Really enjoyed our family's stay here. We booked for 2 adults and our 14 year old son, we had planned a trip to St Andrews and an overnight stay, but we waited to see how the weather looked so by the time we booked there were only a couple of suitable places for the 3 of us in St Andrews for over £240 a night, or this hotel for just over £90. It was about 10 min drive from St Andrews centre, and has a large car park. We checked in at the bar, the young guy working there was really friendly and took us up to our room. There was a kitchen on the way for use by guests which has a washing machine. We had the Junior Suite on the top floor, which was 2 rooms and a bathroom with a connecting hallway. The 2 double beds were really comfy (firm mattresses), there were 2 big tellies, and everything was spotlessly clean. The bathroom looked recently redone, and for the money we paid it was amazing, and we'd stay there again if we're back in the area. I don't think there was a breakfast option, we went to a pub in St Andrews, there were plenty of options there.
Neil
United Kingdom · Couple · October 2026
“The accommodation was excellent for a 1 night stop over. It was fitted out with minimum furniture but the bed was very c”
+Ground floor. Very clean but basic facilities
−Nothing
Julie
France · Couple · October 2026
−Sincèrement, je n’ai pas pour habitude de laisser des commentaires négatifs mais la publicité réalisée pour cet hôtel est mensongère. Rien ne correspondait aux photos. Tout était sale. La moquette était tachée. J’espère au moins que les draps étaient propres. La literie n’était pas terrible. Et surtout, c’était très bruyant car très proche de l’axe routier. Si on avait pas payé aussi cher, je ne serais même pas restée dormir.
Juan Alberto
Spain · Family · October 2026
−La calefacción estaba desenchufada y hasta que nos dimos cuenta la habitación estaba completamente congelada