Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 35 reviews.
Donald
United States · Couple · August 2026
“We didn’t stay, we drove back town to find another hotel”
−Rugged farm. White Horse Stale doesn’t describe- no building was white, no stable, didn’t see a horse. Not at all what we expected. Too primitive for us. We didn’t stay the night. We left to find another place to stay for the night
Morin
United States · Couple · August 2026
“We did not stay. Setup was not for us.”
+Did not stay . The pics were deceiving .
−The smell when you walk in . Had to share bathroom not for us.
Virginia
United States · Group of friends · August 2026
“Never again”
+The shower and toilet room were wonderfully clean, which we appreciate it. And we made our own coffee in the morning.
−The bedroom was not clean. There was dust on the furniture and on the floor. The sheets were not clean on the bed. It smelled as if there was a dead mouse in the room. We will not recommend this.
Lori
United States · Couple · July 2026
“Great get away in the woods.”
+Located on a farm in a beautiful setting. Enjoyed the animals. Karla and Sam are fantastic hosts and we really enjoyed them.
−NA
Sarah
United States · Couple · July 2026
“A place where I felt cozy and cared for”
+Carla was very communicative prior to arrival. Upon arrival, she immediately made me feel comfortable and cared for. She was so friendly and sweet, gave awesome recommendations for places to visit in the area and even drew out a little map. Her animals were all so sweet. Her home is located in a very peaceful foresty area which is prime for relaxing. Everything was well kept and facilities were clean. In the morning, I woke up to a note offering a banana and farm fresh eggs. As I hadn’t left before she made breakfast, she offered to make me something which was beyond sweet. She knew I was a single traveler and had a day of adventure ahead. I felt extremely cared for the entire trip. I couldn’t recommend the home and spending time with Carla enough. Thank you for everything ❤️
−N/A. Everything was perfect
Yun
United States · Group of friends · February 2026
+It was such a pleasant experience with both Carla and Sam, they are friendly, warm and supportive host. Carla had provided us very good recommendations for things to do in the Bayfield area. It was a lot of fun interacting with the dog in the farm.
Kristin
United States · Couple · January 2026
“Do Not Recommend”
+Nothing.
−This property and the pictures online were very misleading. We were not made aware that there were others staying in the house, whether that was other vacationers or the owner of the home (The owner of the home lives there, so you were never alone) There were 3 cats roaming in the house that we were not made aware of. The inside did have a foul odor to it. The inside and outside of the property were unkept. There were goats roaming outside around your vehicle and dogs on chains and in cages. There was no key to get in or out of the house if you plan on staying out later than 10:30pm. You are expected to ask for a key and you cannot lock the door to your room from the outside. You have one small bedroom and are expected to share all other amenities (shower, bathroom) with others staying at the time and you are given specific color towels to use. We felt so mislead that we gave up the entire cost of the trip ($526) to stay elsewhere in hotels for the week. We did not stay a single night of the 4 that we paid for.
Balderrama-Trudell
United States · Couple · September 2025
“Peaceful, welcoming, quaint”
+The personal touch of being in someone's home was nice. Loved the property-remote and gorgeous!
Kathy
United States · Family · September 2025
“Stay was ok but will not repeat.”
+it was nice and quite MOST of the time.
−The listing was a bit misleading. While all the information was there, you had to dig for it in the fine print. Came across as very misleading. The listing should also specifically mention any animals IN THE HOUSE, as many people have allergies.
Kurt
United States · Couple · August 2025
“Unique home stay experience with amazing hosts”
+The hosts were so friendly and provided wonderful suggestions for area activities and dining. We enjoyed our visits with Carla and Sam over coffee in the mornings. The house cats were cute and friendly. The shared bathroom facilities were always clean. Gabriel the sweet dog greeted us each time we arrived back at the property. The goats, chickens, ducks and sled dogs added to the eclectic atmosphere and made us feel we were having a wonderful and unique experience. Picking blackberries and apples was an unexpected bonus. We read the property description and reviews in advance, making us aware this was a rural home stay. Thanks for a great stay!