Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 96 reviews.
Jenny
United Kingdom · Couple · November 2026
10.0“Fabulous lodge stay , nr Killin , Loch Tay”
+Unique , warm , comfortable clean dog friendly lodge , by beautiful stream little waterfall , beautiful location by Loch Tay , close to Killin
−Everything was wonderful !!!!
Ronnie
United Kingdom · Couple · September 2026
6.0“Pleasant stay , just small things that left bad impression on me”
+Location, seclusion and peaceful
−Shower very poor, pillows wafer thin not comfortable at all Balcony posts rotten and unsafe when leaned on
Christopher
United Kingdom · Couple · August 2026
1.0“Would never ever recommend - we went for an anniversary getaway and wish I had went to the local park and camped out!”
+The location was decent, we went on a couple of forest walls.
−The property was so dated it was like being transported back to the 80s. The furniture looked like it hadn’t been changed since before I was born! The decking was wet so turned into a slip and slide. The sofa and carpets were that bad we resorted to sitting outside in the rain on garden furniture as we didn’t want to even sit on the sofa or chair. We tried to contact the numbers on the welcome pack and booking.com site that were supplied and no one answered when we had questions around the electricity which was another shambles. I left 5 or 6 messages and emails and never got a response. I received an email the following day reminding me to tidy up and put linen in the provided bag but no response to any of my concerns or questions. The lack of contact was terrible. I have no idea what the cleaners or upkeep team do as the place had a horrible smell to it. It was unbelievable how bad it was - we had to leave the door open and sit outside in all weather as it was so foosty. Add to that, they charge over £180 per night for this, it’s a disgrace. They then have the cheek to charge 4.50 extra a day to use the electricity which is a lottery if it will stay on.
Scott
United Kingdom · Couple · August 2026
2.0“Property in need of upgrade attention to give value for money.”
+Location
−Constant damp smell throughout property, unsafe glass and wooden porch fence, wood rotten and a lot of movement, decking wood rotting in parts too.
Rafal1979
United Kingdom · Solo · June 2026
10.0+Amazingly situated place with sauna for raining days. I will recommend to everyone, you will not regret it.
John
United Kingdom · Couple · June 2026
4.0“Somewhat disappointing,”
−I selcted this property because it said it was secluded, it wasn;t. The property is quite tired and run down and needs some tlc. It was clean and the bed was comfortable to sleep in. The ovwn did not heat up.
Helene
United Kingdom · Couple · June 2026
9.0“Enjoyed out stay loved the location but a few things could be improved upon like the sofa very old plus decking slippy a”
+Location
−Slight smell of dog and sofa old
Christina
United Kingdom · Couple · June 2026
5.0“Comfortable but very poor communication from owner”
+Beautiful location, very comfortable bed
−The balustrade on the decking was very loose and unsafe, we couldn’t get the oven to work and we could not get hold of the owners for advice
Pauline
United Kingdom · Couple · April 2026
8.0“Will definitely be back, loved it.”
+Loved the sauna, bed was very comfortable, everything was very clean. Little welcome box was a nice touch.
−Decking was very slippery, not the best for people with walking issues. Condensation in morning was awful and there was a faint damp smell but I suppose inevitable given the location. Didn’t spoil our stay though.
Martin
United Kingdom · Couple · April 2026
10.0“A gorgeous cabin, felt good to get back to nature.”
+Waterfall lodge was as described, but also better. I am so glad the bed was so big (super king) and comfortable. My partner is very tall and I didn't even know he was in the bed. I read all the reviews before I arrived and I'd like to respond to them: The blue lights in the bedrooms were EASILY covered at night. The sofa isn't brand new but it's still very comfortable and has a lot of life left in it The sauna was excellent - let it warm up and sit in there for 15 mins! You'll be soaked with sweat. When there's two people you don't need to wait as long. The huts behind aren't that close at all and it feels very private because there is no through road The kitchen was well equipped albeit basic so do bring all the extras for cooking. The TV has live TV but it's not a smart TV (just an FYI) There is a speaker but I thiiink it needs an aux lead? There is a lovely walk down to the old castle from the cabins which is quite magical. Thoroughly enjoyed our time abs would go back.
−Na