Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 200 reviews.
Ian
United Kingdom · Couple · October 2026
“Very enjoyable in the main. Beware friday and evenings, loud live music but that is also a part of this lively cenue so”
+A proper, old style pub. Comfy but unpretentious accommodation, great breakfast and friendly staff
Christina
United Kingdom · Couple · October 2026
“Very good”
+Room was very clean and tidy, the breakfast was very good and the staff were very friendly.
−The location was ok but nearer to town would have been better
Daphne
Netherlands · Group of friends · September 2026
“Basic but comfortable stay”
+We stayed here because we were heading to St. Michael's Mount fairly early the next morning. The hotel and pub are located in a harbor area, and the surroundings look a bit rough around the edges. However, there was a lovely walk along the water towards Penzance, where we enjoyed a delicious pizza from a food truck while looking out over the sea. We finished our meal with an ice cream from S. Jelbert's, highly recommended! We went to bed early, as we were exhausted from our road trip, and the noise from the pub didn't bother us at all. Breakfast the next morning was delicious! Wonderful, fluffy scrambled eggs and great coffee, served by a super friendly hostess.
−We are from the Netherlands and are quite tall, so the low ceiling in the room wasn't exactly convenient for us. We bumped our hands against the ceiling and the light fixture a few times.
Robert
United Kingdom · Couple · September 2026
“Brilliant staff but need help - basic room!”
+Only thing was the staff!
−No reception and checking in a nightmare as only one member of staff doing bar and checking in - she was brilliant but unavailable! She gave us a complimentary drink which was much appreciated as we had to wait so long to check in whilst she served customers! Also the room was basic and noisy! We love staying in pubs but could hear everything! Then in morning shower had no hot water but breakfast was great and again the staff amazing! Just wish the accommodation could match the staff!!
gaynor
United Kingdom · Couple · September 2026
“Short visit to attend a show in the minack theatre”
+Lovely old inn with character , room was clean and functional , breakfast was lovely freshly cooked and served by very friendly staff it’s a quirky place with history which adds to it’s charm
−I wasn’t sure where to park when I arrived but was fortunate to be able to to park right outside the door but I believe there is a short stay car park in the area
Linda
United States · Group of friends · September 2026
“Quaint and comfortable lodging in the heart of Newlyn.”
+The historic Swordfish has lots of character and exceeded our expectations for comfort and cleanliness. The location is great: on the edge of the harbor and fish market and blocks from cute shops and restaurants. Staff were helpful and breakfast was large and delicious. I highly recommend.
Jane
United Kingdom · Couple · September 2026
“Nice location, friendly atmosphere”
+the room was very large with a large bathroom and sea view. The owner/staff were really helpful and nothing was too much trouble. We were made to feel very welcome. The room is above a pub and we were there at the weekend when there was a live band. We did not mind this, the band was very good and we opened the bedroom window to hear the music clearly rather than go downstairs into the pub after a long day touring. The music ended around 11pm, so should not trouble most adults. There is parking nearby which is in fact free from 4pm to 8am.
Emma
Netherlands · Couple · September 2026
“It was memorable and we'd come back to Newlyn for sure!”
+The staff was honestly amazing, just as the location of The Swordfish Inn. You are amidst the cutest part of Newlyn and Penzance. Everything was clean, the room was cute and the shower was nice. The breakfast was really nice.
−The bathroom was a bit outdated and could use a redo and also the bed was pretty shitty. Good to know is that the Inn is rather popular and will be noisy until 11 and 12 am on a Saturday .
David
United Kingdom · Couple · September 2026
“Very good stopover for our trip to the isles of scilly”
+The staff were excellent cooking us an early breakfast which was very good
−The mattress could do with an upgrade
Andre
Switzerland · Couple · August 2026
“Great room and breakfast.”
+Good pub stay. Great spacious room. Good full english breakfast. There are not many places for eating nearby. Go for dinner early or book a table in advance.
−Can get a bit noisy in the evenings but it is a pub nevertheless.