Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 23 reviews.
george
United States · Couple · February 2026
+Peaceful relaxing vibe. Lovely decor and welcome from host Karen.
−Can't think of anything 🤔
Shingo
Trinidad & Tobago · Solo · June 2025
“Home away from home on a small, simple and beatiful island”
+1. The host. Karen was cheerful, hospitable, kind and extremely helpful. She always tries to welcome her guests and to ensure that they are comfortable, safe and enjoying their stay. She is also keen in improving her service. She asked for my suggestions in this respect and took note of them. 2. The establishment. The Pilot House is small, but is well equipped, clean and comfortable. The decor and amenities are tasteful. To enjoy small and simple island life on Eleuthera, it is important to have a good base. The Pilot House hosted by Karen just offers that.
−It would be great if a kitchenette would be installed in the common area. It would allow to enjoy time at the hotel even more because the guests would be able to prepare simple meals, especially breakfast, if they do not want to or cannot go out.
Karice
Bahamas · Couple · May 2025
“Exceptional”
+It was nice no complaints
Clarke
Bahamas · Couple · April 2025
“It's was a pleasant stay had a ball”
+There were no breakfast .just need more light on the outside
−Outside is to dark and I didn't see any security
Dw
Canada · Solo · March 2025
“The perfect small-scale relaxing getaway location!”
+Just a lovely spot. The owner is very friendly, gracious, and kind. Everything was comfortable and convenient.
Edgar
Dominican Republic · Business trip · January 2025
“Exceptional”
+Is a very nice and cozy place, Karen is a very friendly host and is always making sure that you are having a good stay. I loved the cleanliness and comfort of the room, also the quality of the toiletries.
Ian
United States · Family · January 2025
“Beautiful, extremely well equipped and one of the best hosts to work with”
+Karen is a wonderful host, and made sure we are fully informed on how to check-in and provided additional value in figuring out transportation, locations for food, and was generally extremely friendly and helpful!
−Nothing much. The place is stunning, well-kept, and serene.
Denise
Bahamas · Solo · March 2024
“Good”
+It beautiful space. It felt like a spa experience. A good place for quiet and serenity.
−The low internet connection and phone service.
Rosa
United States · Couple · January 2024
“Karen and her place are really great, def getting back!”
+Really beautiful property, surrounded by plants and nice touches in the bedroom like the shower oil made a difference.
Carla
United Kingdom · Couple · December 2023
“Karen is one of the most hospitable hosts, nothing is too much trouble and truly wants to make sure your experience on t”
+When it comes to creating the perfect haven of tranquility, Karen excels in providing an exceptional experience for her valued guests. With meticulous attention to detail and an innate understanding of what it takes to instill a sense of ultimate relaxation, she has mastered the art of crafting an oasis that surpasses all expectations. From the moment guests step foot into Karen's establishment, they are enveloped in a warm and inviting atmosphere that instantly melts away the stresses of everyday life. The carefully curated ambience emanates a sense of serenity, with soothing colors, soft lighting, and tasteful decor that effortlessly blend together to create an environment that is visually stunning yet still exudes a homely charm.
−Everything was perfect.