Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 119 reviews.
Nadege
Switzerland · Solo · November 2026
7.0+Nice hotel but very over priced
Shari
United States · Couple · November 2026
1.0“wouldn't go back not worth $800”
+nothing. the hotel lobby and verranda were nice.
−room was tiny, bathroom tiny, no vanity, no frig or microwave. resort fee was $30 per night per person, but got nothing for it but free wifi and parking.
Marlin
United States · Solo · October 2026
10.0+Great
−Nothing
dawn
United Kingdom · Couple · October 2026
10.0+Location, outdoor fire pit was a bonus
s clark
United States · Couple · October 2026
5.0“If no disturbing wallplumbing noises stay would have been more than okay.”
+Friendly staff
−Plumbing noises in the walls.................disturbing. Hotel is old - but in good physical condition. Bathroom nice - but imagine the interior plumbing is old - and the loud plumbing noises in the walls? - expect not to have that happen at the premium prices involved for staying there.
J7892LNlindaw
Family · July 2026
10.0“The best Hotel”
+Excellent. Everything you would want is here. Including friendly staff, including front desk, bellboys, cleaning services. waitstaff, etc.
laurensV7776IR
Family · July 2026
10.0“10/10 experience, can't wait to go back!”
+We just returned from an incredible stay at The Otesaga over July 4th weekend. Every moment of our stay was incredible. The front desk staff was warm and attentive. We didn't have to wait on a long check in line and were greeted with fresh water. The amenities are incredible. The lakefront staffed helped us get in and out of kayaks and paddleboards with ease. It was so luxurious to be able to just wake up, throw something quick on, and get right into a kayak without any fuss. Even on a busy weekend, everything was so smoothly operated. Nothing beats that view of the lake- crystal clear, glimmering water. So clean and refreshing. My family spent hours in the heated pool overlooking the lake. The view was incredible and there is attentive waitstaff who bring out food and drinks. There are also staff who lay out towels for you. The 4th of July Ice Cream Sundae Bar was such a nice touch. There was also face painting and balloon making from BJ the clown which made the weekend even more special. My kids were on Cloud 9! Our room was spectacular and overlooking the lake. Everything was spotless and well maintained. My kids loved sitting on the windowsill overlooking the view. I am very pi
AtParallel40
Couple · June 2026
6.0“Read before booking in the summer”
+Wish someone had posted this before booking our reservation. I am torn on how to rate The Otesaga. Five stars for the pros, but one for the cons. I’ll average to three. PROS It is a beautiful property. Spectacular setting, tasteful and elegant decor, excellent plus service from every single employee. Attention to detail. Extremely clean. CONS If you go in the summer and you are looking, like we were, for a bucolic, restful getaway, be aware that it is impossible at The Otesaga. Cooperstown is THE mecca for nationwide baseball tournaments for 12-year-olds, all summer, every summer. The hotel is overrun with children, and they improvise baseball games on the lawn by the lake that the adults sometimes join. And they scream. And they screech. Non-stop. Everyday, as people understandably do in a sports game. It was fun to watch for fifteen minutes, but then the unrelenting screaming ALL AFTERNOON LONG gets to you. Forget sitting in the dreamy veranda. “Oh, but at 5:00 they move them to the front lawn,” according to the front desk. I can’t imagine those guests with lakeside rooms with that ruckus outside their window all day. We are lucky we couldn’t get one. Bottom line- You are in a de
didit2015
Couple · May 2026
10.0“Lovely!!!”
+What a beautiful hotel and the view of the lake is amazing. We were there before all the summer things-to-do were available but still one of our favorite trips.
Michael
United States · Couple · April 2026
10.0“We truly hated to leave!”
+Gorgeous. Well cared for. Great staff that all enjoy working there. Concierge gave excellent thoughts and recommendations.
−Not one thing!