Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 200 reviews.
255aronm
Business trip · August 2026
“Fantastic!”
+The Mayton is absolutely exceptional! From the moment we arrived, everything felt thoughtful, beautiful, and incredibly well done. The property itself is gorgeous, with so much charm and character, and the attention to detail throughout the hotel really sets it apart. The atmosphere manages to feel upscale and luxurious while still being warm and inviting. Our room was beautiful, exceptionally clean, comfortable, and well-appointed. The bed was incredibly comfortable, and every detail made the stay feel special. The staff was also wonderful,friendly, welcoming, attentive, and genuinely committed to providing a great experience. The location in downtown Cary is fantastic and makes it easy to enjoy everything the area has to offer. There are only two very small areas of opportunity. On-property parking is not available, so guests have to park across the street. It wasn’t a major inconvenience, but dedicated hotel parking would make an already seamless experience even better. I would also LOVE to see full-length mirrors added to the guest rooms. When you’re getting dressed for dinner, an event, or a night out, having a full-body mirror would be incredibly helpful. Those details are mi
“Good location but customer service needs work.”
+Good location and cute INN. The price was reasonable. However the ac did not work well in our room and it was hot. We told the front desk and nothing was done to compensate us. We were told the manager would give us a call.
“A Wonderful Place to Stay”
+The Mayton is a beautiful hotel. Great location. Wonderful and friendly staff. The restaurant, "Peck and Plume", is excellent. I highly recommend.
“Highly Recommend!”
+My girlfriend and I are locals in the Raleigh/Cary area and decided to book a night at The Mayton to celebrate her birthday , and it absolutely delivered. Sometimes the best trips are the ones closest to home, and this was a perfect reminder of that. The hotel has a wonderfully quaint, boutique feel that you just don't get at larger chain properties. The location in downtown Cary is ideal , walkable and convenient without feeling busy or touristy. The real standout for us was Peck & Plume. The food was exceptional, the service was warm and attentive, and the whole dining experience felt special without being stuffy. Exactly what you want for a celebration. If you're a local looking for a night away without the hassle of travel, or a visitor wanting a charming alternative to the big Raleigh hotels , The Mayton is the answer. We'll absolutely be back.
“Always a great experience and excellent service”
+We always enjoy staying at the Mayton. The staff is always friendly and the guest rooms are immaculate. We love the restaurant and the food is excellent!
“Cute and Quaint Hotel”
+This hotel is perfectly positioned in the center of Cary’s downtown. We had a great time staying there. It was cute and quaint with areas to sit and relax both inside and out. Only suggestion: - tell folks about the free parking lot across the street as well as the permitted parking area The rooms are very comfortable and updated. They have a desk and a sitting chair as well as a nice sized closet and dresser. The bathroom Is also very nice. There is a really nice park with fountains and a botanical garden as well as restaurants in walking distance. There are many trails nearby as well. Very safe neighborhood. Very walkable. We walked to most places that were in the neighborhood. Lots of cute coffee shops nearby as well as other types of food for lunch, dinner, and snacks. Free parking near the hotel and across the street.
S1037DUjenniferc
June 2026
“Quiet Quaint Boutique Hotel”
+The Mayton located in downtown Cary is a lovely place for a traveler to stop. It is walkable to restaurants, shops and a lovely park. We were there on a Sunday so we missed the Peek & Plume restaurant but will try to visit when we return. The team is very courteous and Dana gave us perfect recommendations.
michaelmcg84
Business trip · June 2026
“You’ll Never Be Disappointed!”
+Best hotel in Cary! Can’t beat the friendly atmosphere created by their staff. The food in Peck and Plume is outstanding! Rooms are cozy clean and quiet. Right in the heart of Cary with great running walking and alternative food options nearby.
N7945HUjm
Family · June 2026
“Quaint and cozy downtown retreat”
+Downtown carey is a quaint cozy location across from park and down from art building. Accommodations: Room #303 (deluxe king), floor 3 non-ADA cozy and authentic feeling on Academy rd. Room has a distinct attic feeling rather than the other exterior rooms that are straight walls. Amenities: Mini-fridge, coffee maker. No microwave. Accessibility & Logistics: For travelers navigating with mobility aids (manual or motorized wheelchairs), this property offers accessible elevator access. Parking: The property offers a small, first-come-first-served onsite lot. Dining & Service: The polite, central hospitality is a highlight. No complimentary breakfast. However, there is Peck and Plume on site for breakfast, lunch and dinner with 15% off for guests.
“Beautiful Hotel in a Great Location”
+Really enjoyed our state at the Mayton. The staff was really friendly and helpful. The hotel and rooms were very clean and no musty or old odors (I think hotel is fairly new). Great location, walking distance to a lot of restaurants, and only a short drive to downtown store areas. Also right next door to a park that was nice to walk (and for people traveling with kids, had a nice play area). Would definitely recommend!