Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 200 reviews.
Kathy
United States · Couple · October 2026
10.0“We return to the Jetty every year because of its location, comfortable accommodations, & reasonable”
+The location, right at the Cove beach & Cape May lighthouse, is the best feature of the Jetty. The beach at this setting is gorgeous & it is one of the best places to watch the famous Cape May sunsets. The hotel is one of the old fashioned beach hotels, not one of the modern luxury resorts, but its quaintness is a part of its charm. The rooms are very clean, equipped with a small refrigerator, microwave, & coffee maker, & the beds/mattresses are extremely comfortable. There is plenty of closet & dresser space to store clothing. Each room has an outdoor sitting area with chairs & a small table with a view of the beach. The hotel has a nice pool, & the chase lounge chairs, umbrellas & outdoor furniture were just updated this year. The pool water was sparkling clean. There is on-site parking for 1 car per room, which saves a lot of parking fees when visiting the beach or downtown attractions, as the Jetty is within a comfortable walking distance from many of downtown Cape May attractions, including the Washington Street Mall & restaurants. Finally, the staff are friendly, courteous, and always ready to attend to your needs.
−It would be nice if the pool was heated. I also wish that this was a pet friendly.
Anne
United States · Solo · October 2026
8.0“sweet place, great location, comfortable, clean, excellent staff”
Rachel
United States · Couple · October 2026
6.0“This is a great location, no frills hotel.”
+Location was great, at the end of the road right by beach access where everyone goes to watch the sunset. Room was clean, hotel was extremely quiet since we were there in the off season, even though the rooms were booked. We loved that the wifi was strong and we could access Netflix and YouTube on the TV.
−The bed was a bit soft for my personal preference, not poor quality or sagging, just extremely soft (I'm a back sleeper who likes more firm support). The room was definitely damp but that is to be expected since it's literally right next to the beach.
Harlee
United States · Group of friends · September 2026
8.0“Meets expectations!”
+Location was great. Room was clean.
−The bathtub didn’t drain and shower pressure wasn’t good.
Brenda
United States · Group of friends · September 2026
8.0“I enjoyed the Old Fashion Beach motel vibe!”
Stephen
United States · Couple · August 2026
9.0“Great stay”
+Location staff pool hot and great water pressure
−Chairs outside of room not very comfortable
Arthur
United States · Couple · August 2026
9.0“Overall we were pleased and enjoyed our stay”
+The beach was very close. The location was ok. Did have to drive for meals and that made parking hard
−There was no clock in room and air conditioner was very noisy and couldn’t adjust temperature
ANDREW
United States · Solo · August 2026
9.0“The location is golden. This well kept reto-ish charming and whymsical motel just became my top two favorite stays!”
+Superb location. A warm, genuine and lovely check-in. -Real conversation without the common programed responses. Parking perfect. Solid walls kept noise level down. A/C unit was clean and functioned great! Charming plants and pool area tidy. Would definitely come back and stay.
−No dislikes about this property.
Roberta
United States · Group of friends · August 2026
9.0“Very pleased with the stay.”
+Perfect location. Felt like the 1950's!! Very special.
−TV size
D'Agostino
United States · Couple · August 2026
8.0“Good place for the $$ and great location”
+Close to beach and clean
−Older property , very dated