Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 200 reviews.
K81RHpeggyk
Couple · April 2026
“Great memories.”
+Great location and wonderful staff. Many fun restaurants and bars as well as many options for more upscale dining.
tangelle
Couple · March 2026
“Long weekend at the house”
+Spent a long weekend at the house. Great atmosphere and lots of history. Great location and the view is awesome. The staff is good and for the most part is supportive. The room shows its age as the dehumidifier runs non stop and I had to empty it once a day. The paint is peeling and the windows rattle when there is a strong wind. The bed was super comfortable and the AC cools the room nicely. We had trouble with the drain on the bath tub which was never corrected - I used a rag to keep the water in the tub. The noise from the bar and the food truck is distracting when laying around the pool as the fence is right up to people sitting and eating. The price is a little high for such a run down place. Several leaks visible on the ceilings, railing on stairs missing parts, etc. but it has history and is quite old. Comparing it to the neighboring properties, I would probably go back next door on my next trip.
dbr3000
Couple · March 2026
“Perfect stay at Southernmost House”
+My girlfriend & I just got back home from a stay at Southernmost House, 3/19-22/26. We went to Key West for my bday, and our experience couldn’t have been better. We stayed in rm 108 across the brick street from the main house, a large room with living room, dining area, full kitchen ( my gf has special dietary restrictions so we cook) , large bedroom & bath. Beautiful & so comfortable. Wraparound porch with its own private courtyard. At one point we had a shower malfunction so right away we were given use of rm 109 while our shower was being promptly repaired. Every need was catered to. Big thank you’s to all the Southernmost House staff, and most particularly to the very kind gentleman at the main desk who checked us in & checked with us periodically to see if we needed anything. He was a gem. Embarrassed I can’t recall his name, but he seemed to always be there ! We both give our highest recommendation for SmH, and hope to return ASAP
paulmK9993XG
Couple · March 2026
“Paul and Nancy's vacation”
+This was our third stay at this property and as always we were well satisfied. This is a great site with a great deal of historical significance. Everyone from Presidents to World leaders and some not so great people such as Mafia types have stayed here in the past. It has to be very difficult to keep a property like this in great shape as well as provide great service but they do. We did notice that there were some "attention to detail issues" such as painting and caulking that needs updating but that's an ongoing thing that we hope they stay ahead of in order to keep this a must stop while visiting Key West.
sjderes
Couple · March 2026
“Beautiful hotel but beds need upgrade”
+The mansion house was beautiful very well kept with tons of historic features and artwork inside. The pool was also very nice. Free bottled water was included throughout the stay. We really enjoyed sitting at the seaside Café and tequila bar. The pizza was amazing. Breakfast included in the stay was a nice perk (pastries, bagels, fruits, yogurt, coffee and tea). Parking is an additional fee of $25/night. They have about 6 spots available. Staff was friendly. A major downside of this hotel is at the beds. Need to be upgraded. They are extremely hard and after four nights it was difficult to function with so little sleep. I I travel frequently and very rarely have such trouble sleeping due to the mattress. At the price point and the overall concept of the hotel, I would expect the beds to be a bit nicer. Even a pillow topper wouldhelp if they aren’t ready to replace the mattresses. There’s also construction going on on the south Street side, which is disclose on the website, however it is worth mentioning if anyone is staying in the next few months. The construction starts early in the morning as is expected, but there is no sleeping in at this hotel. The reason I rated this with thr
stacyc103
Family · March 2026
“Fantastic experience at an iconic Key West landmark!”
+Aside from the beautiful architecture, history and perfect location (beach + Duval St), the rooms are clean and elegant, and the service outstanding. Elia gave us a great check-in experience (so helpful after a long drive...). Special thanks to Dean, who gave us a fantastic tour and took wonderful care of us during check out :) We will be back!!
josephfS3623BH
Couple · March 2026
“Southernmost mansion”
+Beautiful accommodations and great location! Exceptional service.
donhT2304UK
Family · March 2026
“Perfect Place”
+Perfect location, very nice, clean room, fantastic view, friendly, helpful staff. One annoying rooster is the only complaint, but not a serious one.
Dream27958363941
Couple · February 2026
“We could not have envisioned a more pleasant first trip to Key West”
+The most gracious and professional and pleasant staff and lovely experience. The historic house, large rooms with high ceilings and location on the south end of Duval is ideal for quiet relaxation. We loved the sunrises and sunsets bottle from the warm saltwater pool deck. Outstanding breakfast of fresh baked local pastries and fruits.
K1892TGmaryk
Family · February 2026
“Bad”
+My experience in this hotel was unfortunately very disappointing. From the moment of my arrival, I noticed inconsistencies with what is promoted as an adults-only hotel. Upon entering, I found 2 girls running all over the house, which clearly contradicts the concept that the establishment advertises. In addition, I witnessed a very unhygienic situation in the reception area: a dog urinated on the front desk carpet, something that I consider unacceptable in terms of cleanliness and sanitary control. My discomfort increased the next day during breakfast. The tables in the outdoor area were dirty, with chicken droppings, and the constant presence of these birds in the surroundings made it impossible to enjoy the food with peace of mind. The number of loose animals inside the facilities significantly affects the guest's experience. In general, I consider that the hotel does not meet the expectations it promises in terms of an exclusive environment for adults, order and basic hygiene standards. Personally, I wouldn't recommend it.