Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 56 reviews.
Hiker Trash
United States · Solo · August 2026
3.0+PROS:: The period restoration and decoration was great! The bed and pillows were comfortable and we slept well (you will want ear plugs or noise cancelling headphones... See cons). The AC worked very well, and the inside temperature was very comfortable. The tub was very comfortable to soak in and taller people will likely find the tub long enough to accommodate. Check-in and check out was completely painless and the remote process worked well. Loved that there was a mini fridge w/ freezer and microwave. All were clean and worked well. Breakfast was meh (including in pros as well bc it was more or less as advertised)
−CONS: We REALLY wanted to love this property, but there was absolutely zero noise attenuation (cannot emphasize this enough). It felt like we were sharing a room with the downstairs occupants. We could clearly hear everything when the downstairs occupants were speaking in a normal, even softer than normal, voice as well as the zippers on their luggage. I have no doubt this goes both ways; we did our best to tip toe and whisper. Also, you could actually see into the downstairs unit via cracks between a few of the floorboards. Glad no one cooked downstairs while we stayed. We would not stay here again or recommend this place to anyone else because of the above issues. The water temperature on the tub should be hotter. Filling the tub with only the hot tap yielded a warm, not hot, bath that cooled quickly. Breakfast needed fresher fruit with more selection (it was red apples, clementines, and bananas; they looked like they had been there a few days). Would have preferred keyless access to the rooms and not just building. The keychains were bulky.
Julianne
United States · Couple · April 2026
9.0“Really enjoyable and an honor to stay in such a historic sacred place”
+The location was great, we didn't get a breakfast, I am not sure if one was provided or not. We booked both the Canton room and the Rajah room. They were beautifully decorated and it was centrally located (within walking distance to all the restaurants and tourist spots) but still far enough away for privacy. The shower was really nice (spacious). I really appreciated the designated parking spot. Parking is a premium in Salem.
−There was a group staying below us in the Silbee's suite and we could hear every word of their converstaion crystal clear (they were speaking at normal volume) this made us realize that when we were speaking to each other, it needed to be at a whisper if we wanted to maintain privacy. I think it is simply the age of the building. I do not think they built it in the 1800's with sound attenuation in mind. They also have a kitchen so when they were cooking, the odor will be strong in the Rajah room (directly overhead). We weren't in the room long enough for it to be an issue, we were always out and about site seeing.
Chrisopther
September 2025
8.0+The staff was wonderful the only glitch we didn’t have any extra outlet paper and the one mostly used one we had didn’t last had to call and ask for more. But besides that I would give them 5 stars
Nicolle
Family · August 2025
10.0+The Silsbee Suite was lovely! Its def just for 1 or 2 ppl even though the kitchen is huge there is only 1 queen bed and a couch. You also habe acess to your own private patio but we were out all day and didnt really utilize that. This property is in walkimg distance to everything you need to get to and see in Salem. It is an old house and you can hear EVERYTHING! Even the other guests if they sneeze or laugh so just be aware of that. I would def stay again
+Was a very beautiful room. Wife loved the loved the tub in the room. Definitely going back one-day.
+It's our second time at Silsbee! We were at the Rajah room the first time, and now at in the Canton room. We loved our stay. Quiet, not in the middle of everything BUT close enough to walk everywhere. The Mercy Tavern near by (3 min walk) is a MUST! Best burgers in town! We had an AC issue on a day of 105, and the owner was very quick and responsive and had good options, although we were able to quickly fix the issue! Breakfast is hold almost in a museum place! So pretty! We love Salem, and will probably be back at this inn!! I love the idea of encourage little businesses!
+We loved our short stay at Silsbee’s…our room was beautiful and comfortable, and Patrick was so helpful and communicated with us quickly and thoroughly.
“Historic stay”
+Loved Salem. So much history. Every house seemed to be historic and well maintained. Amazing to stay in one. They brought an extra chair when we wanted to eat in our room the first night. The breakfast was ample in a comfortable historic (again) room. Really enjoyable. Great food, candy shop and national park site a few blocks away.
“Historic, lovely, affordable!”
+Came into town for a wedding and got to stay at this fabulous B&B for a very nice price. Walkable from everything touristy and beautiful in town including the waterfront about a block away. 2 restaurants and a coffee/bagel joint right around the corner. The main house was very cool and had a museum feel with some original carpentry and masonry. The Rajah room had a brand new bathroom with a huge comfy bed and a fancy clawfoot tub. There was air conditioning during the day, but we kept windows opened for a lovely sea breeze at night. They had a mini fridge and a microwave in the room as well. We can't wait to go back and stay there again honestly. The continental breakfast was yummy. They even had custom tea that was delicious.
+Beautiful property. Close enough to walk to all the town attractions and free assigned off street parking. However the stairs to the 2nd floor are high and steep. There is no insulation in the place. You can literally see the room below through the floor boards and it sounds like the people down there are in the same room. For us that meant a very loud group of people who kept us up. At no point did we see anyone who ran the place. Everything came via email. A code to the door, how to get in, how to leave the place, etc.. The bed was extra firm and we both ended up in pain each morning, plus I think the shower needs a PHD to work it.