Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 200 reviews.
Robert
Australia · Solo · May 2026
8.0“Great location, near Central station”
+Great location
−Checkin and checkout process is clunky
Audrey
Australia · Couple · May 2026
6.0“Convenient position for our purpose - exorbitant cost due to the NRL magic round -”
+Location suited our purpose - Room was large - Shower area needed mold to be addressed Breakfast as not included The receptionist was most helpful on arrival
−Cleaner shower & bathroom area
Chris
Australia · Family · March 2026
8.0“Very comfortable, very close to public transport and within easy walking distance to the city sights”
+I booked two rooms - mine was more updated, well set out, and super comfortable. The other room was older in style but still very comfortable. This older room had extra soundproofing slide windows, so I'm told it was very quiet. Also, Julian on reception was very friendly and helpful.
−My room, which looked beautiful, unfortunately was not sound proofed for exterior noise and the traffic lights just below meant it was very noisy. It also had weird lighting switches which took me ages to figure out - instead of simple on/off switches with added dimmer function they were unmarked dimmers that had to be pushed in to turn on or off.
David
Australia · Couple · March 2026
6.0“Not up to standard”
+No breakfast
−Dirty stained cups Key fob failed to open main door Phone not working to contact reception
Stephen
Australia · Solo · January 2026
6.0“Quiet, comfortable and well positioned facility which suited a one night business trip adequately.”
+The room was quiet and comfortable with a good shower, and was located close to my business destination.
−After hours check-in was complicated as the reception is only manned during business hours. The hotel does not provide any breakfast and there was nowhere close by to secure a good breakfast. The television was limited to free-to-air stations. One streamer would have been appreciated? There were no shelves of any kind in the shower cubicle, meaning all bottles had to remain on the floor.
Terry
Australia · Couple · December 2025
10.0“Awesome”
+Location
−Management was very helpful
Jessica
Norway · Family · December 2025
8.0+Beds were super comfy
−The hallway on the 6th floor smelled terribly of cat pee which made me wonder how clean the carpets are 🤢
Teneil
Australia · Family · December 2025
7.0“Beautiful old building in prime CBD location”
+An amazing old building that would be incredible if fully restored (though I understand how cost prohibitive that would be). The Rothbury is still full of character and just a fascinating place in time. I particularly loved the heritage elevators! The rooms were very spacious, quiet and clean, and the Wi-Fi was reliable.
−General wear and tear/disrepair, food left behind by previous guests (as mentioned in other reviews I've seen). Carpets in the hallway had a distinct stale smell. Check-in was complicated by the fact that the online check in link eventually took me to a confirmation-type screen saying "you are checked in" with no information on how to actually get into the building or retrieve a room key. I'm not sure whether this was an error in the page loading or something similar - could easily have been a one-off issue. In any case, when I called the after hours contact, I was walked through getting a lobby safe open to retrieve the key (though I don't know how we would have gotten into the building in the first place if another guest hadn't let us in) and the rest of the stay passed without incident. Do note that parking isn't included in your booking price. I booked Saturday afternoon to Monday lunch directly across the road at the Cornerstone parking lot for $75 total.
Perera
Sri Lanka · Solo · October 2025
8.0+Offered me a free late check out
−My room didn’t have a view which is not good since I stayed 4 nights
Nick
Australia · Couple · October 2025
8.0“Apart from those small issues, loved it and would stay again.”
+Beautifully decorated, comfortable, great location.
−No soap in the bathroom. No info about the wifi password. No response to attempts to contact the place via Booking.com during our stay.