Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 200 reviews.
kristinaeS2586CS
Couple · February 2026
“Charming and homey”
+This is charming and out of the way. A great budget pick. The manager gave us excellent advice; and we found a fabulous dinner restaurant and great breakfast spot frequented by locals. great coffee too! Be aware- stairway climbs needed to access rooms.
DBdbarker2
Couple · January 2026
“Great stay in Frenchtown, Saint Thomas”
+After a long day of air travel, we stayed at Olga' Fancy for one night in Frenchtown, St. Thomas before heading to Saint John for the week, and it was the perfect start to our trip. The host, Candy and house cat Buddy were incredibly informative and communicative, providing clear directions, helpful local tips, and everything we needed to know for a smooth stay. The property itself was beautiful, with a stunning pool and an amazing view that made us wish we were staying longer. The location was ideal for an easy transition between islands, and the peaceful setting helped us relax right away after travel. We would absolutely recommend this stay to anyone looking for a comfortable, scenic, and well-run place to spend a night (or more!) in St. Thomas. 10/10 would recommend.
441quiets
Family · December 2025
“Not bad but wouldnt rebook”
+Clean place however more like a motel. If you have mobility issues proceed with caution. There are a lot of steps, but the scenery is unbelievable. Do not come to this site unless you have a vehicle. Taxis are expensive. Roosters and cats are around. Actually enjoyed the animals. Friendly upon arrival but if your used to a actual hotel- look elsewhere.
LaureenF109
Group of friends · December 2025
“Peaceful hideaway”
+Eddie and Candy were the best! Very responsive and helpful. Room was clean and king bed was comfortable. Amazing view (room 4)! Plenty of food and beverages well within walking distance. Loved the Twisted Cork, Pie Whole, and Frenchtown Deli (deli had bevs and snacks you could take back with you - sandwiches were big enough to split and very reasonably priced). Enjoyed pool days, island tour with Ricky, and complimentary coffee. The creamer was delicious! ;) This trip was exactly what we were looking for.
+The drive up to the property was very bumpy and rocky. The alley’s getting to the property are very tight. When coming back to the property after hours, there’s a man who closes the gates so that you’re unable to get to the property and you have to get out of your vehicle to move the gates just to get past. Although we understand that the property is right on the ocean we had a huge water bug (roach) in our room. I wish we would’ve been told beforehand that the property/island does not have drinking water and it was very nice of the property owners to give us one bottle of water for our three night stay. I would say that the property is absolutely beautiful, but the walls of the rooms are paper thin. My Husband and I for sure overheard the couples next to us enjoying their adult time alone and let’s just say they were not shy about it at all. Overall, it was an okay stay but we wouldn’t stay here again.
+Very cute and private retreat. The owners/managers were very accomodating! Ocean view room was stunning!
33388Mary
Solo · August 2025
“Rejuvenating experience at Olga's Fancy”
+My water's edge room #17 offered spectacular views. The enduring sound of Caribbean waves provided a lovely backdrop during my 4 night stay. I started my day with morning coffee in the Olga's Fancy reception. Midmorning I moved to the pool, which offers panoramic views and cooling water, to sunbath. In early afternoon, I explored nearby cafes. My favorite was French Quarter Bistro. And I concluded my evenings at Oceana, a fine dining restaurant adjoining the inn. Throughout, a very relaxing and comfortable experience.
+We had the most absolute wonderful time at Olgas. The owners were very pleasant and helpful with reccomendations. My only suggestion is adding a microwave to rooms or even to coffee and dining room. We could never finish our food and had to throw it out. Other than that the VIEWS 😲 the staff... superb. Oceana was a wonderful place to dine next door and both places forever in our fondest memories bc the trip of a lifetime resulted in our engagement as well! Thanks again from two boring Kansans. John and Allisha 😉
+My husband and I enjoyed our stay! Great historic location, and within walking distance to many attractions. Eddie made the check-in process easy and offered to call taxi services. Clean rooms with wonderful artwork! Would stay again!
+Room #17 offers panoramic St. Thomas views. In the dark of night, town lights transform the view to the left. During the day, boats animate the energetic waters. The cottage is built at water's edge, which ensures a constant, calming sound of waves. Nearby restaurants Oceana and French Quarter Bistro have excellent menus. And Eddie provides excellent coffee each morning, a wonderful tradition that brings together inn guests.