Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 25 reviews.
“Overflowing with Historical Charm”
+I love historical homes, and stay at them often. This one (built in 1717) takes the cake! It’s beautiful, authentic and extremely well-preserved. It’s literally a museum (open for tours on designated dates), but is also a homey and comfortable place to spend the night. The host / owner, Justin, is very personable, and incredibly knowledgeable about the home’s history, as well as local history. Everything was clean, neat and comfortable. I’m looking forward to finding an excuse to come back and stay again. See the attached photo for my favorite room in the house: the kitchen.
+This place isn’t just somewhere to stay, it’s something to experience. We were only in for a night but the innkeeper went out of his way to make it memorable. If you are a history buff or just like a fun vibe, we highly recommend.
Thiago
Family · September 2025
+The host was great. He was very polite willing to show us all around. Had a great time!
+Absolutely loved our stay here, definitely will stay again. Such a great experience all around the owner is so knowledgeable and friendly also a great cook, breakfast was delicious. Thanks for such an amazing welcoming experience! Definitely a hidden gem we’re so glad to have found!
+Amazing house, owner is wonderful and talks about the history of the house.house is very clean just a beautiful experience will definitely go back
Verified traveler
July 2025
“A Hidden Gem in Massachusetts”
+If you are a history buff, do not miss this opportunity to stay in this historical inn. Don't expect the impersonal and monotonous atmosphere of chain hotels that look the same wherever you go! The host, Justin, has a wealth of knowledge regarding this inn and is eager to share it with you. The inn dates back to the 1700s but the WiFi is 21st century strong! The nearby restaurant, McGuires, has great food and next door is Aroma Joe's where we found the best coffee during our trip to Cape Cod. Immerse yourself in a unique experience by staying here. We would book again in a heartbeat!
+Very charming historic inn run by warm couple who make us feel very welcome and made an excellent country-style breakfast. High recommended!
“Amazing slice of history and hospitality!”
+We thought that the highlight of the weekend was going to be the concert at Gillette Stadium, but as we drove away from the gigantic crowds leaving the Stadium and into the charming quiet countryside, we began our real adventure into history at the Josiah Keith Inn. From the moment that we received the warm and personal greeting from Justin, the actual owner…not a bored night clerk or cold lockbox, we knew this was special. He showed us around this amazingly preserved Inn built in 1717 and coukd not have beeen more gracious to meet any needs. Despite the age of the building and the many artifacts from history, everything was clean and tidy and comfortable. We slept great and enjoyed a most delicious homemade breakfast in the morning. It was delightful meeting the other guests and learning more about the inn and all the people staying there. As if leaving family, we hated to go and lingered over coffee. Honestly, days later, we are probably talking as much about the great concert as we are about the great overnight at the Inn. Don’t miss a chance to stay here!
+The inn keeper was available at all times and very attentive to our stay. The history of the home given by the inn keeper was interesting and informative. Highly recommend.
+Loved the fact they keep as much as possible to original home Made us feel at home I'm a introvert and felt welcome and other guests engaging we all enjoyed atmosphere Only suggestion a better mattresses even an overlay of memory foam would make a huge difference but definitely would go back. He even helped us get easily to Gillette and back with his recommendation