Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 133 reviews.
Aaron
United States · Solo · August 2026
“The stay was great and the host was friendly.”
+Location amd value was great. I didn't run into any real traffic on the way into Indianapolis. When I had any questions for the host they were prompt with their responses and flexible when I had to adjust my schedule.
−I had no concerns or issues.
James
United States · Solo · July 2026
“This is the perfect spot for someone looking for a clean and comfortable accommodations.”
+This is the perfect place for anyone looking for a clean, comfortable, and welcoming stay. Thoughtfully maintained and inviting, it offers everything you need to relax and feel at home. Sherry is a wonderful host and her home is beautiful.
−nothing
Heidi
United States · Solo · May 2026
−not given a door code
Kerry
United States · Solo · April 2026
“Unique and cozy vibe with an amazing host”
+Very unique and cozy vibe. Sherry was very kind and welcoming.
−The location is in a suburb, so great for a family. It was not very close to the downtown area, but still near a lot of neat and fun places.
John
United States · Couple · March 2026
+Cozy, tranquil space in a beautiful home. Plenty of off street parking, optional add ons..the sauna and massage chair were amazing. Sherry is a great hostess and we had a beautiful stay.
Mirwais
United States · Couple · November 2025
+Very clean and good looking rooms comfortable beds great host
−I loved everything
Xena
United States · Solo · November 2025
“Clean, quiet, and cozy.”
+Quiet home, pretty view from the window. Netflix, youtube, prime without ads. Comfy bed and clean linens/towels. Pretty cool.
−Sleeping in a person's home is generally uncomfy but the room and amenities are comparable to that of an actual hotel!
Laurie
United States · Couple · September 2025
“We found a home away from home while going to the races at the Indianapolis Raceway.”
+The location of Indy's Hidden Gem was perfect for the activities we had planned which included attending the drag car races at the Indianapolis Raceway. The property was easy to get to in a quiet neighborhood and fit our need exactly. Sherry was a very warm and gracious hostess making sure we had everything we needed and answering any questions we had. We would highly recommend Indy's Hidden Gem!
−There is nothing we didn't like!
Debra
United States · Couple · September 2025
“Hidden Gem!”
+Sherry is always a wonderful host and she makes you feel like family! Her place is clean, comfortable and always a delight to stay there.
Barry
Canada · Couple · July 2025
+Sherry was wonderful and friendly when we met the next day.
−Sorry to say, Mainly that the shared bathroom was a shock to us, we will never consider such, but the posting said Private Bathroom but it is shared. Second, we arrived a few minutes before the 11 pm deadline after driving all day, but the home [and neighbourhood] was completely dark from street view, which a guest expects to be well-lit as if they are expected. So we were quite afraid that something was terribly wrong, and also could have stumbled on unfamiliar stairs and entrance. We were not sure if we can park our car in driveway. (Only by mail box # and Waze did we feel we're at the right place.) Dave answered the door and seemed a little standoffish and confused, making us feel very unwelcome within ourselves, he soon turned out to be very nice. He was also in the bathroom when my wife needed it badly in the morning, not his fault per se.