Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 200 reviews.
angella
Italy · Solo · November 2026
10.0+Quaint..beautifully taken care of..fantastic staff..thank you Esmeralda! Wi fi worked great as well
−All good
Breanna
United States · Family · November 2026
10.0+Our stay at the Magnifico Firenze transcended our expectations! The staff was incredibly friendly, and let us drop off our bags before and after our check-in/out time. Esmeralda was especially kind and incredibly communicative, always fast with her responses and Florence suggestions. She was truly amazing! The facilities were also very nice, with comfortable beds and a spacious bathroom. There was even tea, coffee, and slippers available for guests. The location was optimal for anyone who wants to stay close enough to the city center (just hop on the tram for 3 stops or a 30ish minute walk and you're there) without all the noise of the active streets. I HIGHLY recommend!
Arundhaty
India · Family · October 2026
10.0“It's like staying at your bestie's place.”
+Esmeralda our host was exceptional! She was warm , helpful, and gave good suggestions about restaurants/ trattorias. She was also very kind and allowed luggage drop -off before check in time.Her communication skills are super and she was always available on WhatsApp. for all kinds of information. I had a lovely stay at Il Magnifico and will recommend to everyone.
−Nothing
Martina
Germany · Couple · October 2026
10.0+We loved the location, the cleanliness and the beautiful architecture of the room. Attention to detail from the host and high level of responsiveness made this a seamless, lovely experience. When I return to Florence, I know where I will be staying!
Chloe
New Zealand · Couple · October 2026
10.0“Walking distance to centre, comfy clean room, 5 star hospitality.”
+Esmeralda was incredible from check to to check out. Went above and beyond to assist us. Great location, clean and beautiful space
−Nothing
Michele
Italy · Couple · November 2026
9.0“Soggiorno Top!!”
+La comodità dei servizi pubblici tutto a portata di mano
−Niente
Lorenzo Franco
Italy · Couple · November 2026
8.0−Sostituire o sistemare il sedile del WC. Sulla stufetta elettrica, fornita di supporto, va controllato il collegamento del cavo di alimentazione
Mawynj
Ukraine · Family · October 2026
10.0+Отличные апартаменты и замечательная Эсмеральда которая решила все вопросы с возможностью оставить вещи до заселения. Подробная инструкция как попасть в апартаменты без привязки ко времени. Апартаменты в стиле винтаж. Есть окно ванна. Кофемашина чайник холодильник. Всё как в описании. Скидка на меню в таверне рядом. Удобная кровать с балдахином и диван. До площади Дуомо 2.3 км
Elisabeth
Germany · Couple · October 2026
10.0+Alles lief absolut reibungslos und einfach, per WhatsApp gut erreichbar, wir haben Esmeralda nicht persönlich getroffen. Preis-Leistung gut
Raisa
France · Family · October 2026
7.0“Buen lugar para dormir par de noches”
+La ubicación está bien para acercarte caminando al centro y visitar los lugares de interés.
−La habitación me sorprendió, escaleras para acceder, sin barrera de seguridad para niños, difícil acceso para personas mayores. Las habitaciones son frias