Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 200 reviews.
Henk
Netherlands · Couple · October 2026
“Great location, friendly staff, wonderful gardens”
+Great location, good service, friendly staff and excellent food
−Staying in the main building above the bar and restaurant can be a bit noisy.
Jacqui
United Kingdom · Couple · October 2026
“Very good place to stay and excellent location.”
+This is the 2nd time we have been and we plan to come again. The location is brilliant with Baslow itself having plenty of pubs and restuarants and very close proximity to many interesting historical places and also superb outdoor activities. The staff are lovely,very personable and professional. The food is excellent.
−My only small criticism would be that the potato rosti at breakfast was greasy but I feel I am being really picky by mentioning it but you ask the question.
NICOLE CAROLINA
United States · Group of friends · September 2026
“Peaceful place”
+Nature, gardens, the food is Amazing, the hotel super cozy and everyone very kind!
Mark
New Zealand · Couple · September 2026
“Quiet, refined, elegant and memorable!”
+Superb room and a wonderful restaurant made for a memorable visit. We wished we could have stayed there longer!!
−Nothing - everything was beyond our expectation.
Donald
United Kingdom · Couple · September 2026
“Outstanding”
+Breakfast outstanding as always - fourth time we have stayed outstanding every time we'll be back
−Nothing
Annabel
United Kingdom · Couple · September 2026
+The grounds were lovely and a good distance to Chatsworth house, good for a long weekend.
−I stayed in Garden 1 and this room was very disappointing due to being above the laundry room which was not advised when showing me the room. I was woken up early by the housekeeping team talking very loudly and letting doors slam. This was not acceptable for the standard in which the hotel present itself. Breakfast was a too formal for us, we very much appreciate you are Michelin guided but we sat down to breakfast at 9am and were not able to order until almost 10am, even after we had asked multiple times if we could please order, which then unfortunately our food was over cooked when it finally arrived.
Lynne
Australia · Couple · August 2026
“Would highly recommend, a wonderful experience.”
+Beautiful property set in immaculate gardens. Rooms beautifully decorated and restaurant was superb.
−We would have liked a lighter meal option at night.
Tim
United Kingdom · Couple · August 2026
“Exceptional service, staff and setting”
+Service and attentiveness of staff exceptional
−No non taster menu service. Would have been nice to have dinner offered rather than taster menu
Richard
United Kingdom · Solo · August 2026
“We thought we had booked for two nights but in fact had booked for one so the room price was very high and not good valu”
+Umbrellas for customers to use. Wall paper. Punch bowl. Hand made plates at breakfast.
−The room although clean and well thought out, was small. The staff were excellent. The original buildings were very interesting architecturally, although some of the decorative statement pieces were a bit naff. We expected a sensational breakfast in view of all the awards continually trumpeted in information displayed everywhere, however it was average.
Hoyle
United Kingdom · Solo · August 2026
“Great small hotel for a celebration”
+Fischers Baslow Hall is a lovely hotel, great for an extravagant celebration. Our room in the main house was on the small size, but extremely comfortable. The lounge / bar and restaurant are very comfortable. There is a choice of a 5 or 7 course tasting menu, which was fabulous. Also a set menu (3 choices per course). Good wine list. Staff were friendly, professional and particularly impressive in the restaurant for dinner. There is a beautiful garden - sadly after many weeks of drought at home, it rained so we couldn't enjoy sitting in the garden.
−Service at breakfast, while very friendly, was less good. One morning we had a long wait and on the second morning the food wasn't as we had ordered it, and the waitress bringing the food didnt seem very interested in that. It didnt spoil our visit but was just not quite as perfect as the rest of the service.