Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 200 reviews.
Yi Tian
Netherlands · Group of friends · September 2026
1.0“Overpriced. Pool photos from listing doesn’t match reality”
+I didn’t like the property
−Extremely disappointed with my experience. Room was old, half the room sockets didn’t work. The picture of the pool overlooking the vineyard from the official website/ booking.com listing are INACCURATE. The pictures make it appear as if the pool is next to the vineyards with unobstructed view. In reality you face a high fence from the pool. Jacuzzi was lukewarm, and off for the day I arrived and only turned on after multiple complaints from other guests. When I arrived in the morning to use the pool, I took off my T shirt/ flip flops (left them on the sunbed) to go into the pool, and the staff took my belongings without checking whether these items belonged to anyone. Breakfast buffet is supposed to be complimentary, but I was then told to sign a receipt - the waiter said this is needed to show I’ve “enjoyed the services” and that I wouldn’t be charged. The receipt listed the breakfast as 35 USD, and asked for a tip. I’ve never had a complimentary hotel breakfast buffet ask for a tip. Overall, I feel that the price is too high given the quality of room/ amenities/ service. If your price is in the ballpark of four seasons, I expect something in that ballpark in return.
Karin
United States · Couple · August 2026
10.0“The perfect staycation for R&R”
+Charming, had everything we wanted, great food options, leisure activities
CyrusR80
Couple · August 2026
10.0“BEST RESORT EVER!!! (luxury + serenity)”
+I love this resort. The room was spacious, the bathroom was large with a soaking tub and massive stand alone shower. The food was amazing, the atmosphere was very serene and peaceful. Even though this resort was in Napa, it was not pretentious at all and I felt so comfortable. I totally want to come back. The best part was the FARM restaurant that had the absolute best dessert ever.
B8021XXmarkd
Family · July 2026
6.0“Still a beautiful resort but needs some improvements”
+Still a beautiful resort, but in need of some attention We’ve stayed at Carneros Resort and Spa more than 20 times over the years, so it has always held a special place for our family. It’s why it’s disappointing to see that, while the resort remains beautiful, it’s beginning to show signs that it needs some investment and care. The grounds and gardens are as stunning as ever and are clearly very well maintained. We stayed in two adjoining cottages, which worked perfectly for our family, but the accommodation is starting to look tired. Simple things such as ill-fitting curtains and general wear and tear suggest the rooms could really benefit from a refresh. The food continues to be a highlight. We thoroughly enjoyed our breakfasts at Boon Fly Café, and the breakfast team at Hilltop were consistently excellent, providing friendly and attentive service every morning. Unfortunately, housekeeping was the biggest disappointment of our six-night stay. On four occasions we had to chase for our room to be serviced. There were also evenings when turndown service had been completed, but the room itself had still not been properly cleaned, which isn’t what you expect from a luxury resort. Wha
carlosaU7545UO
Couple · July 2026
10.0“Memorable stay”
+Once again the Carneros resort does an amazing job making our getaway a magical experience. I will continue to visit when I’m in the area. Rooms were clean and quiet, the beds are comfortable and the yard is impeccable.
PriyaN510
Couple · July 2026
2.0“Do not waste your money/points/vouchers on this hotel. Save yourself the hassle”
+I would like to preface my review by saying I initially only submit my review to Hilton. The hotel manager, Michael Ford responded to my review asking that I reach out to him directly for a solution. His message was essentially copy paste the response he sent to all of the negative reviews on here. I emailed him on July 9th. By July 16th I still had not received a response, so I followed up. I have still not heard back from him or anyone on his team. It seems that this hotel has poor customer service from the top down. We booked this stay using a free night voucher and 170,000 Hilton honors points and the quality of service did not match what was advertised, a luxury hotel. Had I known we would have such a terrible experience, I would have made reservations at the Appellatian in Healdsburg instead. When we checked into the hotel, they had us at the Lavender 1 cottage and the room was not as pictured on the hotel website photos. The backyard area was very grey and did not have a nice garden like in the photos from their website and the room layout was very odd. The bed was facing the patio instead of the TV and fireplace. Because it was facing the patio it was right next the AC whic
Passport279408
Couple · July 2026
10.0“Beautiful resort between Sonoma & Napa”
+Carneros resort surpassed our expectations… we loved the cottage/room- super cozy with a private enclosed backyard space w/ huge bathtub & outside shower that we thoroughly enjoyed! Beautiful flowers and landscaping around the property. Morning breakfast buffet was outstanding with a gorgeous morning view of the hills & vines… Adult pool up on the hill was very relaxing as well! Highly recommend!
zaimojin
Couple · July 2026
10.0“First Wedding Anniversary”
+We celebrated our first wedding anniversary at Carneros Resort and Spa and had an amazing time. The front desk team was incredibly friendly and took the time to acknowledge our anniversary, offering thoughtful guidance on how to make the most of the resort's amenities. As dog owners, we especially appreciated how pet-friendly the resort is. We spent much of our time poolside, where there was ample space among the many day beds. The staff regularly checked in on us,and our dog!,which made the experience feel truly personalized. Thankfully we were able to utilize our free night stay with Hilton at this property. A highlight of our visit was the free Friday community event during the summer. They projected an old-school movie on the lawn, and it was wonderful to see families gathering together to enjoy the evening. The resort also offers complimentary use of a Cadillac for guests wanting to explore nearby wineries. While we chose to stay on-property and soak in the relaxing atmosphere, other guests raved about the convenience of touring the area without having to drive themselves. The overall vibe was peaceful and rejuvenating. We would happily return and highly recommend it to anyone
117sophiac
Family · July 2026
4.0“Not worth the price”
+Did not meet expectations what so ever. We came here for july 4th weekend and paid a premium. I told them it was a special occasion and when we got to the room our keys didn’t work and there were 2 strange men that opened the doors for us. Nothing done for the special occasion that I had told 3 people about. Then my daughter was out there playing on the deck and came back with a handful of splinters. A sign warning kids not to crawl on the deck would have been nice. I really wanted to be able to come back here and recommend this place to friends but unfortunately we’ll be looking elsewhere. Don’t let all the good reviews sway you from looking elsewhere. Such a disappointment. It’s not worth the money.
S7712IElindsayd
Couple · June 2026
2.0“Safety Warning for Dog Owners & Families - Distressing Experience and Dismissive Management”
+We have stayed at Carneros Resort many times because we’ve always enjoyed the pool and grounds. After a previous disappointing stay, we decided to return hoping things would be better, but this visit was deeply upsetting and we will not be returning. WARNING FOR DOG OWNERS AND FAMILIES WITH SMALL KIDS:The private patios are not fully enclosed underneath. They have wide-open decks that leave open access for wildlife to live beneath them, and there are no measures in place to prevent raccoons from entering these guest areas. Our stay started poorly at check-in. The first cottage we were assigned was completely dirty, featuring an unmade bed and used towels on the floor. We were told to wait while they moved us and were promised a glass of rosé, but it never arrived. Things became terrifying shortly after settling into our second cottage. Our 11-year-old senior dog was brutally attacked by a raccoon inside our private "enclosed" patio during daylight hours. The raccoon came directly from the open area beneath the deck. The attack was entirely unprovoked, extremely distressing to witness, and required immediate emergency veterinary care. We had to spend our first day in Napa at the eme