Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 200 reviews.
Josh
United States · Group of friends · November 2026
10.0+We had the BEST experience staying at the Best Western Historical Inn in St. Augustine! While the hotel itself was great, what truly made our stay unforgettable was the incredible customer service from the entire team, especially Sonia, the General Manager, and Virginia! About a week before our trip, I spoke with Virginia over the phone, and she was absolutely wonderful! She was so sweet, helpful, and accommodating. She went out of her way to help us arrange an early check-in and even offered to help decorate the bride’s room to make her bachelorette weekend extra special. She even offered to turn on the Jacuzzi for us despite the chilly weather! 😂 That kind of thoughtfulness and willingness to go the extra mile before we had even arrived meant so much to us! And Sonia, the General Manager? AMAZING! She went so far above and beyond anything we could have expected. She genuinely bent over backwards to make sure we had everything we needed and did everything in her power to make sure our best friend had the most amazing bachelorette weekend possible. It’s one thing to have someone simply do their job, but it’s another thing entirely to have people who genuinely care about their gues
−Nothing !!
Denise
United States · Solo · October 2026
4.0“I would not stay here again”
+I was clean, the staff was friendly.
−The walls were so thin, I could hear people in both rooms on either side of me talking normally. The yelling was horrible! I had to turn up the volume of my TV (after a staff member told me how to connect the TV. The DirecTV box was UNPLUGGED! The bed and pillows were so uncomfortable I had a backache and stiff neck in the morning! This is not the quality of Best Western Hotels I have been to in the past.
Mathew
United States · Group of friends · October 2026
4.0“I’d pass on this one”
+Overall location is easy to walk places
−Suite was not clean. Staff had attitude when my son asked for additions towels for our second day of our stay. Acted as if we were making her go out of her way to get five towels. Floors were so dirty walking barefoot…see picture below …
Nevaeh
United States · Couple · October 2026
8.0“Very comfortable”
+Everything
−Some of the lamps didn’t work.
Maranda
United States · Family · October 2026
7.0“Decent stay for decent price.”
+Clean, well lit, pet friendly, great breakfast,
−Beds weren’t comfortable. Lady screaming, grass in the pet area would be nice.
William
United States · Couple · October 2026
8.0+Property was beautiful and location is perfect
−Bed was extremely hard! Felt like we were laying on one huge block.
Tonya
United States · Family · October 2026
4.0+The beds were comfortable, the room was clean and the location was great close to everything we wanted to do.
−The first room we were assigned the lights did not work we told the front desk and they transferred us to the room next to our first reserved room and when we were in there the A/C did not work properly the fan for the A/C would stick we did not want to change rooms because we already moved to another room before so we dealt with it. I informed the front desk after we checked out of the issue. we also did not feel it was right to charge for parking when it was the hotels personal lot. The Lady on night shift at the desk was not the friendliest either.
April
United States · Couple · September 2026
10.0“You will enjoy your stay!!!”
+The staff was wonderful, breakfast was good! The rooms were nice and clean!
−I liked everything about it.
Deborah
United States · Couple · September 2026
9.0+Hot tub was hot.
Nicole
United States · Group of friends · September 2026
4.0“While the location is convenient for a short stay near the attractions, the hotel is extremely overpriced for the poor c”
+I loved the location of the property.
−The fact that they charge you over $15 per day for parking, but then there is no parking available and they have you parking at the hotel next-door if the parking is full at their location and for someone that has mobility issues it’s very difficult to walk from one hotel to another hotel next-door. Especially at night, which is not safe and there is very poor lighting. The bathroom was not clean and the toilet seat was broken and I had to complain and they were only able to fix it the following day, which made it very difficult to use the bathroom obviously. The beds were as hard as plywood and very uncomfortable luckily I had brought some pillows from home to try to make it as comfortable as possible.