Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 72 reviews.
Brian
Australia · Solo · September 2026
9.0“A quirky bohemian time travelling adventure that I would highly recommend.”
+Nothing was too hard for the owner Ella and her extraordinary cook/ cleaner. The garden for breakfast was a delight.
Sara
United Kingdom · Couple · September 2026
6.0“Pretty family run pension in great location for port and restaurants.”
+Great location and setting.
−Rooms were lovely but a little tatty.
Pia
Belgium · Group of friends · August 2026
4.0“All in all a disappointing stay”
+Good location and nice garden
−We booked two rooms. In one of our bathrooms the shower door was missing (meaning water everywhere) and the mirror was broken. Everything looked shabby or was not well maintained. Staff was also not friendly, we had to wait 20 min well past the check-in time which would be not a big hassle, but we felt like intruding, e.g. we were told not to speak at the floor, while we waited or we were told to not bring food or drinks from outside (which we didn’t plan); breakfast was also not worth it (and we had to wait 45 min after the time they told us its ready).
Bente
United States · Couple · August 2026
9.0“Great place to stay in Büyükada”
+If people makes your trip then this is the place to go. Ela and her staff are as sweetest as could be, willing to go beyond all expectations. Breakfast in the garden was wonderful. New items added every day. The garden was beautiful and the atmosphere relaxing. The hotel easy to find from the ferry terminal. Restaurants of all sorts close by. The rooms themselves are old-time, tall ceiling guest rooms with a newish bathroom added to each room. The rooms feel all old gone-by heydays which was so nice.
−The bathrooms have not worn well (but then it can be difficult to add to an older building if on a budget).
Ahmed Mohammed ali
Egypt · Couple · August 2026
4.0+The location and garden and good breakfast.
−Nice garden with eye for detail. Great location. Warm welcome at first. Good breakfast. The eye for detail is not translated to the room. The opposite; the room was run down and smelled damp. Broken toilet seat,The photo's on booking.com dont reflect reality. There is no soundproofing. Water, clean towels or housekeeping were not provided. The blanket was too small for 2 people and the pillows were so thin, they didnt offer necksupport. For 100 euro's a night and a 4 star rating this is unacceptable. But above all we were not aware that the staff should stay up untill the last guest came in. So in essence there was a curfew that was not communicated. We had a birthday and came in the middle of the night. Where we were scolded for (as paying, unaware costumers). The overall behaviour after that was unpleasent. We didnt feel comfortabele and decided to stay on the island but in another hotel. Which turned out to be a good choice because while we checked out we were told we couldnt bring our own drinks in (which also was not communicated) and we were overcharged for a Coffee. Overall not a pleasent experience; customerservice, communication and cleanliness lack. Price-quality is not r
Dannielle
Australia · Family · August 2026
9.0“Charming old hotel in a great location. Garden is beautiful. The hosts were so lovely and friendly.”
+Charming old hotel in a great location. Garden is beautiful. The hosts were so lovely and friendly. Aircon worked well and there was a small fridge with water which was great.
Louise
South Africa · Group of friends · July 2026
9.0“We loved staying at Anthea Butik Hotel - relaxed atmosphere outside of the hustle of the main tourist centre. We were lo”
+Great location, charming hotel with a very friendly and attentive host.
Simone
Germany · Solo · November 2026
9.0“Erholsam und lecker.”
+Sehr freundlicher Empfang, gemütliches Zimmer, die Einrichtung war sehr liebevoll und es gab überall etwas zu entdecken. Sehr gutes, reichhaltiges Frühstück.
Julien
France · Couple · November 2026
4.0“Vraiment très moyen”
+Le petit déjeuner. La situation géographique. Personnel très gentil
−L état de la salle de bain , photos non conforme à la réalité .
Tanguy
France · Couple · October 2026
10.0+J'ai beaucoup aimé l'accueil très chaleureux et la disponibilité et le grand sourire de l'hôte, ela. La chambre était très propre, et d'un très grand calme au point que le premier soir nous ne sommes pas rendu compte que la fenêtre était ouverte. Les petits déjeuners dans le jardin étaient très bons et très copieux.
−Rien