Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 50 reviews.
Piotr
Poland · Couple · October 2026
10.0“The perfect base for exploring the beautiful Val d’Orcia”
+We liked everything.
−Nothing to complain about.
Cindy
Canada · Group of friends · September 2026
10.0“It was a perfect place. Everything was amazing. The rooms the beds the views the people. Would stay again in a he”
+Location was perfect. Staff were amazing. Nico and his wife were great hosts. Helpful with all we needed. The rooms were beautiful. Property was out of a movie it was stunning. The kittens were a bonus. :)
−That we had to leave.
Andrew
United Kingdom · Couple · September 2026
10.0+Leo couldn’t do enough to help us
−Nothing
Artturomtz
Mexico · Couple · September 2026
10.0“Amazing spot, strongly recommended.”
+We really loved the attention given by the hosts. We have never felt so "taken cared" of. Also, the views are a spectacle. Impressive location.
−We liked everything, nothing to comment here.
noleth
Colombia · Family · June 2026
10.0“Memorable days in Cretaiole!”
+Magical place! Felt like living the Tuscany movie! Charming Details every where. Is a place you don’t want to leave! Nature, the family owners, the experiences (truffle hunt, pasta classes, outside dinner). It’s definitely a place I want to return Thank you creataiole family for stamping those days for a beautiful memory in our lives. The amenities are fantastic. Excellent quality products.
Danna
Australia · Couple · June 2026
8.0“When you see it in the movies and want to experience it in real life”
+Absolutely stunning, most welcoming a home away from home
−Absolutely nothing!
Christopher
United States · Group of friends · June 2026
10.0“Our stay was magical and full of beautiful memories that our family will treasure forever!”
+The location was beyond beautiful, with panoramic views and our hosts were warm and inviting. They made us feel right at home. Our villa was everything we could have imagined and more! It was beautifully painted and decorated inside with a breathtaking view from every window. The beds were comfortable and the bathrooms were well stocked with towels and luxurious beauty products for our use.
Zhixin
China · Group of friends · May 2026
10.0“Wish we could come back someday!”
+Cretaiole exceeded our expectations a lot, and it's because of Nicco and his family. We stayed in the 6-person apartment for 3 days. There are all the things you need for a good stay, such as Moca kettle for a refreshing morning. We used it every day and it's a good pleasure. Besides, we love the breakfast basket (extra pay required). There're fresh fruits, homemade yogurt, bread, corn flakes inside, feeding us for the 3 days (we ate a lot lol). The activities they offer are also attractive and interesting, we chose the farm tour with Nicco and it's interesting to know more about how they do farming and how they raise the animals. Also it's our pleasure to know more about the family history. Many thanks to Nicco and his family for alllllll the things during our stay. The tiramisu Nicco made is the best one we have during our trip in Italy.
−Sometimes birds would stay in the apartment and fight with each other, leaving a pile of feathers. (it's not a complaint. It's an interesting experience for us to live with them, but someone might be allergic to feathers.
Dániel
Hungary · Solo · August 2026
10.0“Toszkána szíve.”
+Minden. Erre a szállásra nem tudunk rosszat mondani. Imádtuk minden részét és minden ott töltött idő fantasztikus volt. Legszívesebben nem is írnám meg, hogy mennyire jó volt ez a hely, hogy mindig lehessen foglalni, de a házigazdáink megérdemlik, hogy mindenki tudja, hogy ennél szebb és jobb helyet nem tudok elképzelni Toszkána szívében. Imádtunk ott lenni, utáltunk eljönni. Minden fantasztikus volt.
−Legfeljebb egy-egy klíma lakosztályonként jó lenne, de ez sem nem tetszett, csak javaslat lenne.
Gaeul
Germany · Family · July 2026
10.0“A Beautiful Tuscan Stay with Wonderful Hospitality”
+We had such a lovely stay. The room was cozy, beautifully decorated with charming antique furniture, and very clean and comfortable. There was a small play area for children in the garden, and we also enjoyed meeting the adorable cats. They offer wonderful activities such as making pici pasta and visiting the farm animals, which made the stay even more special. Above all, we truly appreciated how Nicco’s family took such thoughtful care of us and helped us enjoy the real beauty of Tuscany. A warm, memorable, and truly special place to stay.