Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 81 reviews.
michael
United States · Couple · October 2026
“Beautiful place that makes your stay just that much more enjoyable”
+10 minute walk to any part of historical district. Everything is updated so the ambience is stellar. Was here in March 2026. Had friends visiting from Midwest do told them to meet me here in St Augustine. They were as impressed as I. That should tell you everything.
Colette
United States · Family · October 2026
“Such a beautiful little find”
+I loved everything about this property. It is just like the pictures. It’s so pretty and cozy and quiet! It is close enough to everything that you can walk! I just loved it so much! One of my boys made the comment that this is the best place that we have ever stayed, and I have to agree with him! These are good people!
−Everything was wonderful
Randy
United States · Group of friends · September 2026
“Very nice and clean.”
+Very good location.
Philip
United States · Solo · August 2026
+Nice location. Quiet neighborhood. Somewhat away from the historic district but it is walkable.
Lisa
United States · Couple · July 2026
“Wonder stay! Definitely would stay again!”
+Quiet, clean, and cozy
Dennis
United States · Couple · June 2026
“The Cottage was a private, quiet and restful departure from normal resort vacation stays.”
+Continued and timely communication with our hosts made pre-planning/arrival stress-free. House was clean, well-equipped and ultra-quiet. Internet and streaming services were trouble-free. Plentiful supply of towels and cleaning supplies. Despite the weather and oppressive heat we experienced, HVAC worked flawlessly. Appreciated the labeling of all the light switches. The full-sized washer and dryer were a bonus, especially considering the length of our vacation trip and high temperatures we experienced.
−Nothing the hosts could change e.g. weather temperatures, presence of small lizards/grasshoppers, mosquitos, etc. Neighboring property is undergoing major renovations. Concrete grinding and early-morning construction noises, while not really bothersome, could diminish the quality-of-life for some renters. One suggestion would be to prepare and display a book of area restaurant menus and/or special attractions.
James
Netherlands · Couple · June 2026
“Great location for both the town and driving to the beaches”
+Location was perfect. A short walk into the centre of town but very close to good restaurants. Small extras were all available in the house for going to the beach like a cool box / pack with the ice packs in the freezer.
−Would have liked a filtered water and ice dispenser in the fridge freeze but this is a very minor point and in no way detracts from the overall excellent review. My personal preference for coffee is expresso but the coffee maker supplied was standard for a US house and fine.
Chris
United States · Family · June 2026
+Beautiful home that is well maintained and has all the fun little discoveries there. We found the games drawer on the morning that we were leaving. We will probably stay here on our next visit to St Augustine.
−The walk to get to the historic district was a little farther than I thought when I booked our stay.
Danielle
United Kingdom · Family · May 2026
“Fantastic few days exploring st Augustine's historic district!”
+The property was located in a perfect location to explore St Augustine Historic District & within a very short walk to one of the hop on/off trolly stops and plenty of great food in the local area! The accommodation itself was perfect, tidy, clean and modern with everything we could possibly need. Parking off road was very easy and handy! We knew there was no cot in advance and brought our own - the property has generously sized bedrooms which easily accommodated the cot. The hosts messaged to check in with us and make sure everything was as expected - which it was... if not better! I've already recommended this place to family and friends! We would absolutely come back and stay here again!
Diana
United States · Family · May 2026
“All in all the cottage is beautiful and well kept-I would recommend to anyone”
−The only one problem was the shower/bath tub. It really should be redone as a walk in shower or at lease put non-slip strips on bottom of tub as it was very slippery and thank God for the grab bars or it would have been an accident for sure.