Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 32 reviews.
Wout
Belgium · Couple · August 2026
10.0“Perfect way to experience the beautiful island of San Pedro”
+We really enjoyed our stay at Tranquility Bay! We stayed for 4 nights and we wished we could have been there longer, so much to do and see. The staff are super friendly and helpful to make your stay be as great as possible. We also loved the free amenities like snorkel gear, paddle boards and kayaks. Would definitely recommend fishing of the dock for your own meal once!! To get there is the hardest thing: you can go by boat organised by the hotel (which we found to be quite expensive) or rent a golf cart and drive your way up on your own: the road is pretty bumpy but doable if you take your time. If you do want to rent a golfcart ask the hotel for a rental company they recommend, others tend to rip off tourists.
Lina
Colombia · Couple · August 2026
7.0+The place is very nice for a short stay
−The hotel is very far away from San Pedro. Despite asking the staff about ways to get San Pedro, they never mentioned that the hotel was 20 miles up north and they didn’t suggest a way to get there either. The shower was in bad shape and there was only hot water. We had to ask twice for a repair. Food isn’t great either. Fortunately there is another hotel pretty close (7min walk) where you can find good food
Shenandoah
United Kingdom · Couple · August 2026
9.0“Excellent staff and very relaxing!”
+Spacious and quiet and very relaxing. The staff were amazing, especially Audi and Agustina. The restaurant food was really delicious and massive portions and the cocktails were great too! Snorkels were available for use and the property is right next to an incredible reef.
−We didn’t have daily housekeeping and the kitchen did not have much at all, so it was hard to prepare any of your own food or drinks. A kettle would be good. The journey there by golf cart was very long, but we found it a fun adventure. May not be enjoyable for others.
James
United States · Couple · July 2026
9.0“Short Fishing Trip”
+The staff at Tranquility Bay were excellent! The manager and wait staff were incredibly attentive and helpful during our stay. The food at the restaurant was excellent and the menu changed each day so there was variety for a long stay. The accommodation was comfortable and the AC was excellent.
−My friend and I were visiting to fish. Unfortunately, Sargassam was in the water and fishing was not possible. This macroalgae is prevalent in the northern summer months. If you are coming to fish, book from November to February to avoid it. Its location would be incredible for bone fishing. If you want an escape that is secluded but has excellent amenities, this is a great choice.
Fred
United States · Couple · June 2026
10.0“The name tranquility Bay suits it really well. This is a great place to operate from if you want to explore other parts”
+The snorkeling was great, but the restaurant was probably my favorite part of the whole day, or maybe it was the view off of the front porch of the villa. This place was fantastic.
−There in certain times of the year, the seaweed is a real nuisance, and further down shore stunk really bad, but not there at tranquility Bay, however, did cover up the beach so that you couldn’t really just walk down the beach into the ocean without crossing through a ton of seaweed. But I feel like that’s kind of priced into everything and at Tranquility Bay resort it was a smaller issue than it is at other resorts where it really stunk.
Soukeníková
Czechia · Solo · May 2026
10.0“Anna”
+This place is realy amazing. Paradise! We received a very warm welcome from the staff after our arrival. Staff is very friendly and they made their best to meet every our wish we had. Ever and Axcel are the best guys! Especially Axcel made our stay very special. Room is very nice, with kitchen. For the transportation you can choose the van shuttle (2hours) or their own boat from San Pedro (45 minutes) for a very fair price. If you want they can arrange the stop at the supermarket and you can buy what you need. Water is available in the room for free. If you want you can eat at the restaurant. They have very good food and coctails. Prices little bit higher, but acceptable because everything is fresh and the resort is far away from the town. Beach is beautiful, with white sand. And the Barrier Reef is unbelievable! You can snorkel whole day if you want, directly from the beach. There are beautiful corals on the right/south side of the reef. We have seen dolphins on the reef, nurse sharks, eagle rays, sting rays, lobsters, puffer fishes, moon jelly fish, squids, cuttlefish, and a lots of other fishes. Beautiful place to stay for holiday, one od the best places we have visited.
Adam
United States · Couple · April 2026
10.0“We chose Tranquility Bay because it’s close enough to the reef that you can snorkel right from the beach. We spent hours”
+Snorkeling to the barrier reef from the beach. The eagle rays. No need for excursions. The people. The seafood. Napping in the hammocks. The bird walks. The sunrises. The pelicans and the frigate birds. Did I mention snorkeling to the reef from the beach? The people.
−Sargassum was starting to pile up. It’s all over the Caribbean.
Nora
United States · Family · March 2026
10.0“Great value in remote and peaceful spot on island.”
+The remote location is special and makes you feel comfortable and relaxed. Staff was very accommodating in arranging tours and modifying around travel changes.
−Higher variety of food and beverage availability.
Marlies
United States · Family · March 2026
10.0“A great place for families with kids along the barrier reef. Much nicer than in San Pedro itself. One of the few places”
+The location is amazing, outside of town. We loved the pier with seating and the restaurant, which provided a great area to hang out right over the water, and to avoid the sargassum that is unfortunately along all beaches in the wider area. Great snorkeling with the kids just a few minutes of swimming away. We also liked the kayaks that were available to anyone staying at the report. All the staff is super friendly and personable. They help you pick or open fresh coconuts that are all along the beach on the coconut palms.
−The running water in the unit was so full of chlorine it smelled like a bottle of bleach and our skin stung after showering.
Nichole
United States · Group of friends · March 2026
10.0“Amazing stay”
+Perfect location Beautiful views Very clean Staff was amazing
−The path leading up to the resort