Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 37 reviews.
Chris
United Kingdom · Group of friends · October 2026
8.0“Beautiful house in a fantastic location, but hot water needs improving”
+We had a lovely stay at Toffee Crackle. The house is beautifully decorated and furnished to a very high standard, with comfortable beds, modern facilities and everything spotlessly clean. The location in Staithes is absolutely perfect. Communication with the hosts was excellent throughout. They were friendly, helpful and quick to respond, and we really appreciated their flexibility with our checkout time.
−Unfortunately, the one significant downside was the hot water supply. Although the property sleeps eight people and has two bathrooms with showers, there simply wasn’t enough hot water for everyone. Only one person could shower at a time, and we then had to wait an hour or two for the water to heat up again. Even with just six of us staying, this was quite restrictive, and everyone felt conscious of having to rush their showers. I appreciate that properties in Staithes may have limitations with their heating systems, but a larger hot water tank or improved system really is needed for a house of this size, particularly when accommodating eight guests. It’s a shame because everything else about the property was excellent. We really enjoyed our stay, but the hot water issue was a significant inconvenience and something I think future guests should be aware of. If this were addressed, it would be an outstanding place to stay.
Suzanne
United Kingdom · Family · October 2026
7.0+The house was lovely, needed a deep clean but it was Up to standard. Lovely location, near to the shops, local pubs and the harbour.
−Lack of hot water, if you run a bath no one else can get a bath or shower for a couple of hours. The house could do with a deep clean. The stairs are very steep, I think stair gates should be fitted to the top and bottom of the stairs especially when you know children are staying at the property, luckily we did take one so it wasn’t an issue for us. The location is really nice but if you have mobility issues it isn’t easy getting too and from the car parks, there is no parking near the house.
Sarah
United Kingdom · Group of friends · August 2026
10.0“We had a lovely relaxing family holiday.”
+Spacious, comfortable and cosy.
−N/A
Mary
United Kingdom · Family · August 2026
8.0“Nice house. Not a good view.”
+Spacious and well furnished
−The attic rooms were tricky due to the slopes.
Yvonne
United Kingdom · Group of friends · March 2026
6.0“Good but better explaination of the facilities prior to booking would be helpful .”
+It’s location, the layout of the house, the decor
−It was cold in every room the parking charges were not understood or explained properly. Very expensive if you have multiple cars .. The kitchen was equipped unequally. The hot water quickly ran out of if all was using showers / bath at the same time The fridge was not cleaned it had fish juice in the bottom of it . The green mold around the top bedroom window was unsightly. Wash pods would have been helpful and maybe some basic toiletries
allison
United Kingdom · Group of friends · March 2026
7.0+Lovely cottage feel, location, kitchen lovely
−No locks on bathrooms, when sharing with others its not ideal. I know this has been mentioned on other reviews and it is a real issue. Not enough seating in living room when party of more than 6, the 2 chairs are not comfortable as hard and uncomfortable, we didn't all sit together because of this. Bath in main bathroom seal on door is green and needs removing and cleaning, it was awful.
Stephanie
United Kingdom · Group of friends · February 2026
9.0“Great location with room for 8 adults.”
+Great location, perfect size for us. Lovely and clean.
−Needs locks on bathroom doors. Needs loo roll holders. Needs enough wine glasses for 8 people. Needs enough seats for 8 people in the lounge. Needs a proper sized fridge; such a size for 8 adults is hopeless (especially when the bottle holders in the door are no longer present). We loved the place but those little tweaks would make it perfect.
Linda
United Kingdom · Family · February 2026
7.0“Staithes holiday”
+Bedrooms lovely. Beds and bedding comfortable
−House was unheated on arrival. Everyone felt cold for the first night and next morning until cottage warmed up. No welcome pack. (Wine, flowers, biscuits as most cottages do). Not enough wine glasses for house capacity. No utensil to lift fried eggs out of frying pan. No tin foil, cling film, kitchen roll, salt, pepper, ketchup, mayonnaise..tea, coffee, sugar. We regularly stay in rental holiday cottages and always find these things provided. We brought our own food to cook but had to go out shopping for all of the above items before we could just have a cup of tea.
Jamie
United Kingdom · Group of friends · January 2026
7.0“Disappointing Christmas Stay”
+The property has a lot of charm and is well located
−Minimal or no cleaning had been done. Dirt and rubbish piled up outside the kitchen window. One of the showers was blocked with slimy hair and overflowed through the kitchen ceiling on Christmas Eve.Oven was filthy. Had food remnants from previous guests.
Paul
United Kingdom · Group of friends · November 2025
8.0“Comfortable property in a great location.”
+Good size property in a great location.
−Some minor maintenance required.