Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 27 reviews.
John
United Kingdom · Couple · September 2026
10.0“It was such a pleasure to stop here ever detail had been thought about with care”
+Everything about this property was so well presented
−Nothing
Graham
United Kingdom · Couple · August 2026
7.0“Beautiful location, but significant issues with privacy and accommodation”
+The location of The Smiddy Roshven is beautiful and is the strongest aspect of the property. It is less than half a mile from two quiet, private beaches with exceptionally clear water, perfect for swimming. It is also well placed for exploring the area, including boat trips from Arisaig to Eigg, Rum and Muck, the ferry from Ardnamurchan to the Isle of Mull, and visits to the most westerly point on mainland Great Britain. As a base for exploring this stunning part of Scotland, the location is excellent.
−Unfortunately, the property offers very little privacy. It is less than 100 yards from the owner’s house, and the garden is not private. Several properties have rights of access across it, and dogs regularly pass through off lead. During our stay, the gardener worked outside for a significant period and a window cleaner also arrived. We were not informed about either visit. While the window cleaner was there, my partner had to run into the bathroom to close the window while I was showering, which was extremely uncomfortable. Dog policy The pet restrictions were not made sufficiently clear before booking. The owner does not like dogs being left alone and provides additional rules after booking, including that pets are only allowed in the kitchen. Before our stay, we explained that our dog would need to be left alone on some days, and the owner agreed. He is accustomed to this and has stayed at many properties throughout the UK and the Isle of Man without any problems. However, when we left our older dog at the property for one day while visiting Eigg, the owner told us he had apparently been distressed and that she had considered entering the property to remove him. She confirmed th
Emma
United Kingdom · Couple · July 2026
10.0“Idyllic and beautifully thought out”
+Lovely walk to a secluded white sandy beach, fresh local eggs, great water pressure in the shower, midge nets for the windows so you can leave them open, lovely cosy decor, has everything you could possibly need, parking next to the property, short drive to mallaig/white sands, saw sea eagles above the road to the Smiddy.
−Very warm in summer, I recommend bringing a fan like we did.
Cherry
France · Couple · May 2026
10.0“Amazing!”
+Incredible location. Very beautiful property. Had everything and more than we needed. Gifts on arrival. Just perfect.
−Nothing ! That we had to leave to go home !
mark
United Kingdom · Solo · May 2026
9.0“Calm, peaceful and a great location to enjoy this beautiful part of Scotland.”
+Location very tranquil and quiet. Beautiful surrounding with a lovely bubbling brook a few feet away. Accommodation was warm and very well equipped with excellent kitchen facilities. Bathroom a good size.
−It is an old highland cottage and so the windows are relatively small making the views to the beautiful gardens a little more restricted.
Matt
United Kingdom · Couple · April 2026
10.0“Very comfortable accommodation in a great part of Scotland with lots walking, wildlife & sightseeing”
+Great accommodation,great location.
−N/a
Grant
United Kingdom · Solo · April 2026
8.0“A tremendous location”
+The fireplace in the bedroom and the cosy vibes it produces. The modern kitchen and underfloor heating are also wonderful. The remoteness of the location with peaceful walks to nearby beaches.
−No baking trays and other kitchen essentials not provided like ladles, wooden spoons. A list of what's provided before staying would be nice.
Kirsty
United Kingdom · Family · January 2026
10.0“A Tranquil Place”
+EVERYTHING!!! It's in a stunning location & the property itself has been beautifully decorated - high-end whilst staying true to the rustic charm of the place. Totally spotless & welcome pack put together by the hosts was outstanding. There's a lovely wee burn that runs next to the house & following it takes you on an amazing woodland walk to a gorgeous beach with spectacular views. Our trip was for 3 nights & would have happily stayed for the week - its very special xx Hosts Siggy & Tim are great - approachable & so helpful. Thanks for making our stay amazing 🌟
−There was nothing i did not like. I cannot fault anything about the place.
Geoffrey
United Kingdom · Couple · October 2025
10.0+The remoteness and prettiness were just what we wanted, and the cottage and grounds were clean, comfortable, and well maintained.
−The lengthy power cut across the region meant we returned home for a day and a half mid-term, but the whole of the area was very badly hit by Storm Amy. We were offered an extra day's stay, but it wasn't remotely the owner 's fault. Everyone in the region we met were stoic about the struggles, some without power for 4 or 5 days.
Jennie Fishwick
United Kingdom · Couple · September 2025
10.0“Lovely cosy and luxurious cottage”
+The location was lovely and quiet, the Smiddy was small and cosy but plenty big enough for two
−Not a dislike as such, but a freezer would have been helpful, but we managed fine.