Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 200 reviews.
Stockburger
Australia · Couple · November 2026
3.0“Very basic and dated”
−Considering the property is a fair way and up the hill from shops, some incidentals, e.g. sugar, tea and perhaps some milk would surely be proper. Also as a minimum WIFI is expected to be working, the signal was too weak to reach unit 2 from the wifi router.
Sabrina
United States · Solo · November 2026
8.0+The bed was comfortable. The shower was strong and delightful. The host is super helpful and will facilitate whatever you need.
−There was no internet access in the room but there was access in a common area. However the best access was in the shed alongside the shared washing machine. It would be better if the modem hook up went to the nearby common area which had internet but it was a weaker signal.
Troy
Australia · Solo · November 2026
10.0“Location is a sanctuary like feel with glimpses of the the mountains, beautiful gardens & bird life”
+Location is a sanctuary like feel with glimpses of the the mountains, beautiful gardens & magnificent bird activity!
Wayne
Australia · Couple · November 2026
8.0“Quiet stay, enjoyed the bird life and grounds of the accommodation. Host is very helpful.”
+Quiet location and there was a lot of bird life. The grounds were in good condition. The units have been upgraded over many years and were functional. Being on a holiday, you're only in them for a short time each day. Good to have your own cooking facilities, fridge, microwave and kitchen utensils etc
−No oven in the room. Couldn't reheat a lot of things like pizza, pies etc that are on sale at the local shops. As there is no mobile phone reception, Internet access is the only way to communicate for email and phone calls. The wireless coverage at The Broken Banyan only works in a very small radius of the laundry, where the WAP is located and is overwhelmed with more than 4 or 5 guests online. Wireless coverage needs to be much improved for guests.
Alison
Australia · Couple · October 2026
8.0“Our Stay on beautiful Lord Howe.”
+Beautiful grounds in a very central location. Easy walk or bike ride to both sides of the island. Host Barbara was lovely and eager to help. She will pick you up and drop you back to the airport as well as drop you to restaurants at night. If you're looking for reasonably priced accommodation that is clean and comfortable in a friendly and relaxed place then I can recommend The Broken Banyan.
−Wi-fi wasn't too good in our room but we could go (50mtrs) to Transit Lounge to get reception.
Thomas
Australia · Couple · October 2026
9.0“Good value for money and a lovely host.”
+Inexpensive & clean.
Colin
Australia · Group of friends · October 2026
8.0“3rd trip there and can’t wait to go back”
+The position and how peaceful it was
−Nothing really
Crawshaw
Australia · Solo · October 2026
9.0“Clean and tidy, quiet and comfortable.”
+The attendance of the hostess, Barbara. She was quite splendid. She took me from the airport to the apartment and the reverse when I left. She is wonderfully attentive to the needs of both her quests and her appartments.
−Everything was perfectly fine for me.
Janette
Australia · Group of friends · May 2026
10.0“Very relaxed and private, would certainly stay again.”
+It was clean and cosy and had everything you need for an enjoyable stay. Outdoor BBQs were very handy. Barbara was lovely and very generous with her time, collected us from airport and drove us to dinner. Just remember to bring all toiletries and tea/coffee bags.
Gareth
Australia · Solo · May 2026
7.0“Wifi needs improving, and a bit of maintenance needed, but nicely equipped kitchen”
+Well equipped kitchen. Comfortable bed.
−No wifi to the rooms. Every time I wanted to connect, I had to walk around to stand outside the laundry room. Also, the owner made you read the pass code off the back of the router in the laundry room instead of printing it out on the information sheet in each room, or even simply putting up a notice on the wall. I suggested to the owner that she get a wifi extender or two, but she didn't seem to be interested. She also said that the washing machine had broken down, seemingly quite a long time ago, and she was 'waiting for someone to come over and fix it'. If customer service is a priority, it would be best to buy a new machine and then work out what to do with the broken one. There was a draft excluder on the bottom of the door in my room that got dragged back every time the door closed, leaving a big black arc on the carpet. It wasn't a great introduction. When I used the push-down hand basin plug in the bathroom, it stuck down. I had to use my fingertips to unscrew the top, otherwise the hand basin was unusable. I realise that maintenance may be difficult to organise on the island, but it's important.