Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 12 reviews.
Simon
United Kingdom · Couple · September 2025
9.0+This was a very interesting property part way up the hill with lovely views over the harbour. The property was a little compact as could be seen from the photographs on the booking site but with everything you could need for a short holiday. The manager was very attentive and organised a taxi from the port. Vicky the owner was very responsive to our messages before arrival. Altogether a property worth visiting.
−As a bit of a minor point, we felt that the outdoor seating area at the end of the property was a little bit of a wasted opportunity. A little bit of sensitive pruning would retain the look and lushness of the area but make it more user friendly and vastly improve the views over the harbour. We moved the chairs to the flat area by the door. To be fair, it was coming towards the end of the growing season.
Irene
Cyprus · Solo · August 2025
9.0+I had a wonderful stay! The room was absolutely amazing, cozy, cute, and beautifully designed. It had such a warm and inviting atmosphere. One of the highlights was the stunning view of the port, which made the experience even more special. I highly recommend this place to anyone looking for a comfortable and charming stay!
Rob
United Kingdom · Couple · July 2025
6.0+Location in the port. Clean and tidy.
−1. Casual manager, was not able to be professional when asked to respond to a reasonable request regarding an issue. Seemed to resent his role to serve the customer. Was rude and disrespectful. 2. Lack of clothes storage. Small rail is not enough. 3. Cooking facilities poor. Extension lead around water potentially unsafe. 4. Inadequate mirror facility. One small shaving mirror not enough. 5. Outdoor furniture could be more comfortable and inviting.
Carolyn
France · Couple · June 2025
10.0“Perfect for us”
+We loved it here and could have stayed forever 🥰🤣
Menia
Greece · Solo · September 2024
10.0“Exceptional”
+Clean, comfortable, view, in and out of nature, the shower, minimal yet thoughtful decoration, 3 minutes walk to all amenities.
−There are a few steps to go up to the house, maybe 20 steps. Pack light and enjoy!
Andrianna
Greece · Couple · August 2024
6.0“I rent the property for ~160 euros per night which was definitely too expensive for what it offers.”
+The location is nice because you are in Vathy and you can walk to its center. However, the properties around are under construction and thus the neighbourhood is not very pleasant.
−Too small and hot, the door from bedroom to the kitchen was too narrow and short so that we bumped our heads during the first day. No black out curtains or shutters exist and so the morning light wakes you up from 7am. No nets on the windows exist and the property is quite hot. The AC in the bedroom hits your head when you sleep. Could be a pleasant experience if it was a cheap solution, but it is expensive and definitely not value for money.
Athena
United Kingdom · Couple · July 2024
9.0“Would book again, it was superb!”
+The property is great, enough for a couple with a large bedroom, very well equipped kitchen and bathroom. There’s even a laundry machine outside you can use. The outdoor sitting area is also great to relax in the early morning, afternoon and evening when it’s not sunny! Location wise despite having to go up a few stairs, it’s perfect as you are just a few minutes from the supermarket and main area in Vathy. Communication with the host is also super direct.
−There’s a step to get into the bedroom from the kitchen, so you need to mind your head getting in and out. We knocked ourselves a few times and it was painful. Also, if there was a fan for those who don’t use a/c would be a great addition, especially since the a/c is directly pointed to the bed and there’s no net on the windows, so we didn’t leave them open at night to avoid mosquitoes from coming in. The host does provide mosquito repellent and electric machines to use however, so that’s super good of them.
Timothy
Netherlands · Couple · August 2023
10.0“Exceptional”
karfi
Greece · Couple · August 2025
10.0+Ήσυχο μέρος στο κέντρο του Βαθύ Πολύ φυσική σκιά και δροσερά Ο Αριστοτέλης παρά πολύ ευγενικός και πρόθυμος να μας βοηθήσει στα πάντα !
−Από τον χώρο στάθμευσης μέχρι το κατάλυμα είχε πολλά σκαλιά
Eirini
Greece · Couple · August 2025
8.0+Το κατάλυμα αυτό ανταποκρίνεται εξαιρετικά στην φιλοσοφία του νησιού. Ένα σπίτι αρκετά όμορφα ανακαινισμένο, με μια υπέροχη αυλή που σε βοηθούσε να ηρεμήσεις και να νιώσεις ότι όντως βρίσκεσαι διακοπές. Όσα αρνητικά είχαν γραφτεί σε προηγούμενες κριτικές είχαν διορθωθεί και ο Αριστοτέλης ήταν πάντα διαθέσιμος και πολύ εξυπηρετικός.
−Το μόνο που μας δυσκόλεψε προσωπικά ήταν τα μαξιλάρια στο κρεβάτι. Ενώ υπήρχαν δύο μαξιλάρια για κάθε άτομο ήταν και τα δύο πολύ μαλακά ενώ θα μπορούσε το ένα να είναι πιο σκληρό σε περίπτωση που κάποιος το προτιμάει έτσι. Επίσης στην κουζίνα θα μπορούσε να υπάρχει και μια φρυγανιέρα ή τοστιέρα.