Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 93 reviews.
Ann
United States · Group of friends · November 2026
9.0“View of the Minster is great!”
+Location, space, comfy beds and everything we needed in the kitchen
−There was an unexpected set of stairs as the elevator only goes to the 1st floor and we had large luggage
Steven
United States · Family · November 2026
9.0“A great flat in a perfect location. We hope to stay at Stonegate again the next time we visit York.”
+This is a lovely flat. It has two spacious bedrooms and bathrooms. Everything was very clean and the beds were comfortable. The location, inside Old York, was perfect with several pubs, stores and restaurants within easy walking distance. The host had a nice welcome gift for us. There was also notebook with information about the flat and the city that we found very useful.
−The outside keypad was a bit fussy (a very minor issue).
Charlotte
United Kingdom · Couple · November 2026
10.0“As we are not as young as we were being so central made our 3 night stay ideal. Not far to walk to anywhere. And car par”
+Very central. Safe. Comfortable with lovely welcome gift.
−Nothing
Judy Bue
United States · Solo · October 2026
10.0“Fabulous central apartment”
+Fabulous location with a beautiful view of the Minster. Large rooms with comfortable seating and a well appointed kitchen.
−There is nothing that I could complain about
Diane
United Kingdom · Solo · September 2026
10.0“York trip”
+Right in the centre of York. Clean and tidy, replied quickly to any queries, beds really comfortable and a handy hamper with necessities included. No noise from the street below.
−Nothing to dislike about it
Michael
United Kingdom · Couple · August 2026
7.0“Lovely apartment, but with parking difficulties and noise issues”
+The apartment was lovely, lots of pluses. Very well equipped, it was very hot when we were there, so had to open doors and windows when possible. Cool fans were useful. Cannot fault the property itself
−It was difficult to park nearby.. we did find a space across the road, but had to make a few journeys up the stairs, then across the courtyard, then more stairs. The main issue was the noise from No. 8. There were 3 children from about 5 - 12 who were outside in their back yard shouting and screaming a lot of the time, not what we expected! We were trying to watch Wimbledon, but had to close the windows. It was so bad, we decided not to stay the last night. The mother and one of the children were kicking a football constantly against the wall underneath the lounge window during that afternoon - which was the final straw. It meant we lost the afternoon and evening in the apartment as well as the next morning. We contacted York Stays and they did offer us a future one night stay at Stonegate and told us that it was the owner of No 8's grandchildren staying with them. We did not feel that we would want to go back to that apartment on the basis that it could happen again. A real shame. Never had an issue like that before and we have booked many apartments with Booking.com
Leilei
United States · Family · June 2026
10.0“Will stay here again!”
+We loved our stay in this fabulous apartment! It’s located in the center of York yet when you get into the complex you will be amazed that the apartments are in a very quiet courtyard! You are steps away from the famous Betty tea house and there are couple very cool soap and candle stores right across the street! The pictures don’t do justice for the apartment itself. The rooms are spacious, the interior looks new, the furnitures are comfortable and you are provided with plenty of utensils. Although it doesn’t have air conditioning, when you open the windows cool breeze rushes in. It’s very comfortable even in the middle of summer!
−None
Karen
United States · Group of friends · May 2026
10.0“Wonderful stay in a beautiful city”
+Great location, very clean.
−You have to walk a ways into the property to get to room.
Ian
United Kingdom · Group of friends · April 2026
9.0“Excellent - we shall be booking again”
+Location was perfect and the facilities were exceptional. Good response from the company as we accidentally left items when we checked out but they were sent on to us promptly.
−Rusty chairs and table on balcony
Jayne
United Kingdom · Group of friends · March 2026
8.0“Really good and would stay again”
+Spacious, clean and had everything we needed. It was in a fabulous location. Such a lovely welcome pack left for us. Beds comfortable.
−Car parking wasn’t on site but close enough that it wasn’t too much of a problem. Maybe could do with a bit of modernisation.