Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 26 reviews.
Janet
United Kingdom · Couple · July 2026
“Unique property in a brilliant location on a beautiful island.”
+Brilliant location - easy to find and close to everything . Fantastic views over the sea and listening to the waves crashing onto the rocks at night was wonderful. Quirky features were lovely.
−There were a few issues (lack of any running water mainly) which whilst were resolved it would have useful to have an information book that could have been easier and quicker to resolve. Very poor internet connection, which we know is a 21st century issue, and we were on holiday so getting away from it all, but useful when trying to contact owner and keep in touch with family back home.
Elaine
United Kingdom · Couple · June 2026
“Lovely stay at Poseidon House. Perfect location to explore Mandrakion”
+The property is in an excellent seafront location. The noise of the waves was lovely. The upstairs patio was spacious and the sunbeds were comfy. There was shade at certain times of the day. It is a lovely quirky house with some beautiful features and thoughtful additions. The owner responds to messages promptly. Lovely restaurant just across the way. Short walk to the nearest beach.
−The stairs are quite tricky to navigate so not suitable for elderly or infirm. The shower head was not attached to the wall. We reported it but unfortunately it was not fixed during our stay. We couldn't use the oven as it tripped the electrics.
Ronnie Coxon
United Kingdom · Solo · June 2026
+The rustic feel of the house and the balcony. It has everything you need for a comfortable stay. The host was responsive and helpful. You have everything you need within walking distance.
Dimitris
United Kingdom · Couple · August 2025
“Unique experience, few inconveniences”
+The location is breathtaking making the experience truly unique. You live and sleep hearing waves crushing at the walls of the house. Next to it is the most scenic cafe/taverna of the island. The sun sets in the sea and you are provided with an exclusive stunning view.
−Hot water and wifi were not working during the period of our stay and the manager was not able to find a solution. The staircase is very steep and dangerous. There were plenty of small ants in the kitchen so you had to be careful where to leave food
Clemens
Austria · Family · July 2025
+Wonderfull Terrasse direct on the sea. Very nice lovely made details.
Neil
United Kingdom · Couple · October 2024
“Lovely property, facilities poor - stay spoilt by the incompetent and unresponsive absentee owner”
+Location, lovely artwork and craftsmanship throughout the property. Roof terrace was a great place to relax, read and enjoy the sea. Centrally located to access all requirements - restaurants, bakers, grocery etc. And to take trips to the small inland towns and the amazing volcano crater.
−We were without any water supply to the property for 17 hours, with the result that use of the toilet, shower, washing, cooking etc was impossible. The owner failed to send either a plumber or buckets etc of water in our emergency. Additionally, the washing machine failed to drain. There was no handle on the Italian expresso machine, the fridge light did not work, mugs with handles missing, only one fruit bowl, no proper cooking utensils etc. Most of these have been pointed out in previous reviews but the owner has failed to remedy. We also had an evening ferry departure and requested assistance from the owner to store our baggage for the day, he had no solution - yet most of the very many other self-catering properties we have stayed in have local arrangements in place. In summary the facilities and arrangements lack a manager/owner who has competence (and pride) in customer care!
Elke
Austria · Couple · September 2024
“Beautiful place becoming shabby”
+The place with this terrace is magic
−Everything would need a little renovation- starting from there wardrobe door to the laundry rack, the washing machine is not really working properly, …. There is a damp musty smell when you first enter the house, there should be done some ventilation before guests arrive. The host sends a not very friendly message at the arrival with instructions what you should not do for any reason. No further communication! The house itself could be great.
Angeliki
Greece · Solo · July 2024
“Very good”
Ginetta
United Kingdom · Couple · June 2024
“Architcturally interesting house in an incredible position on the sea with fabulous terrace!”
+Poseidon House is an amazing quirky property right on the sea. Akin to sleeping on a boat we fell asleep to the waves crashing on the rocks below. You can swim below the house or on the beach a few minutes walk away. The terrace has to be one of Nisyros’ best… huge with shade and comfortable sunbeds. We had everything we needed to enjoy the great town of Mandrakion with its fabulous restaurants.
−A great house for two people who happily share a double bed. Not so comfortable if you need an extra bed but we managed!
Emma
United Kingdom · Couple · May 2024
“Nice but very basic. Tricky to find at night. Good position otherwise. Terrace fantastic but very basic … the coffee per”
+Loved the sun terrace and the style of the house.
−We arrived at night from the ferry. Everything was closed. No proper directions or anyone to ask. It was difficult to find. No name on door. Key safe didn’t work but luckily found key in cupboard. Just hoped we’d found the right house but we DID!!!