Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 28 reviews.
Marcia
United States · Family · September 2026
7.0“The private bay beach is fantastic!”
+The location, on the bay, was what sold us on this location.
−There was a lot of confusion as to what cottage we rented, which we didn’t know about until we arrived. Booking.com, apparently, showed all the photos from both cottages, and it was misleading. We ended up in the apartment, which is up a steep set of stairs. We managed but for a nearly 80 year old it was a bit tough and certainly unexpected. The flat is fine, however, there isn’t any sitting room, such as a small living room where we could gather and relax. The kitchen table was the only place.
Josolynn
United States · Solo · September 2026
9.0+We absolutely loved having the private beach out our door! It was a perfect spot for us and our pup!!
−The only downfall was no gathering space for family inside beside the kitchen. But our weather was beautiful so we gathered at the beach!
Kathryn
United States · Solo · August 2026
9.0+We loved Little Haven. Having the beach right there was great for a group of adults so we could all come and go as we were ready. This is not fancy, but that's not what we were looking for. Comfy and had all the basics we needed. We grew up going to the Jersey shore and this is what we remember and love, true cottages. We enjoyed sitting under the umbrellas by the water, swimming, eating in the backyard, drinking our coffee looking out at the water from our bedroom/living room , and much more. Host was kind, easy going, and gave some good tips.
−One of our group needs a soft bed, the beds were firm. This was good for most of us but just an fyi for those who need softer.
Barri
United States · Couple · January 2026
8.0“We enjoyed our stay.”
+The location was lovely. The ferry and restaurants were within walking distance. The private beach was so peaceful and quiet. The bed was very comfortable. The cottage was very quaint and interesting, loved the old hardwood floors.
−As an older person, I was not fond of the step up into the bathroom. I also did not care for the door lock - the owner had to help me load an app onto my phone so we could lock and unlock the door. It worked fine, but I needed help with setting it up. Parking was also scant, once we found a spot, we did not move the car until we left.
Cecilia
United States · Couple · October 2025
10.0“Highlands hidden gem”
+Mini-beach along Shrewsbury River provides quiet nature, birds, scenery, boat views, NYC skyline view. Rustic bungalow very comfortable
Dominique
United States · Family · August 2025
10.0“Little Haven Felt like a Home Away from Home”
+The location was walking distance to a nearby bagel shop, pizza place, and bar. Sandy Hook Beach was a short drive away. The space was cozy and had everything we needed for a comfortable stay with 5 adults. The neighborhood was quiet and nice to walk around at night. The owner was responsive and attentive. Looking out over the bay at night and seeing the NYC skyline was something else.
−The on street parking was kind of limited but there is a municipal lot at the end of the road, a very short distance from the house. We were able to pull up in front of the house and unload our things then go park the car. So it wasn't the worst thing in the world, especially if you dont mind walking.
PEGGY
United States · Group of friends · August 2025
10.0“Highlands Beachfront Bungalow”
+Perfect location. Perfect for multiple people. Waterfront property. Wonderful bagel place one block away.
−We loved everything.. It would be nice to have a tv in one or two of the bedrooms in addition to the one that is in the kitchen.
Alexander
Canada · Group of friends · July 2025
10.0“AMAZING”
+Beach access, space, comfort
−No laundry
Trinity
United States · Group of friends · June 2025
9.0“This was our second stay in the highlands and everything was great!”
+Rob is fantastic! We had a cozy trip despite the rain. Everything was clean and comfortable upon arrival.
William
United States · Couple · April 2025
9.0“Cozy bungalow in a perfect location.”
+Excellent location right on the bay. The bungalow has some adorable antique furniture. There are plenty of grills, kayaks, chairs and fire pits for outdoor activities. Unfortunately the weather didn't cooperate.