Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 75 reviews.
Beth
United States · Group of friends · October 2026
“Enjoyed the stay!”
+Location downtown. Walking distance to quaint coffee shops, crafty stores and restaurants. Loft decorated well and love the brick exposure. Clean and quiet area. Plenty space and if have children have game room- foods all, air hockey and skeeball. Price was reasonable.
−Walk upstairs to get to loft did not bother us but just know stairs. You cannot sit outside at night if that’s what like to do. Quiet area you have whole building to self and very large rooms.
David & Shannon
United States · Solo · May 2026
+Since we didn't stay, it's hard to say what we liked. I liked the pictures on Booking & the price.
−The steps up are steep & kind of narrow. And dark. Not what you want to be toting things up & down. We were shocked by how dark the lighting was. Atmospheric, yes. But depressing and didn't match the booking photos for brightness. I think there should be photos of the stairs and the property pitched toward more toward young groups. We are fairly active people (we like hiking, it's why we were there), but I don't want to feel like I'm having to hike up to my place of rest. My friend & I felt like we needed flashlights just to navigate the loft, esp. at night or a gloomy day. We just felt unsafe. And we drove over a hundred miles to find this out! Plus, we were charged a "housekeeping" fee in spite of the fact we were there for 15 minutes. What's to housekeep?
Laura
United States · Couple · May 2026
“This property wasn’t a good fit for a couple of seniors on hiking journey but would be a great place for a group of youn”
+It was close to restaurants and not far from the hiking trails and sites.
Sue
United States · Group of friends · January 2026
“I felt good about my choice”
+Everything
−Nothing
Serenity
United States · Couple · December 2025
“Weekend Getaway - Secluded with perks of being in town!”
+Loved the vibe, location, and amenities!
−The creepy sliding door that the staff verified when we were about to leave that there isn't a connection to another room. Would have really relieved some stresses if we had known that ahead of time or if the door looked lockable by more than a piece of wood 😂
Cheryl
United States · Couple · December 2025
“We had another great stay. Shirt walk to multiple dinning spots.”
+This was our second stay. We enjoy Logan’s proximity to Hoking Hills and Nelsonville. A combination of nature hiking, eateries and shops
−Steep stairs ( please put a lock on upstairs entrance to prevent children from opening and falling down steps) and some of the game room games need replaced. Jute box needs repair. ( wasn’t working last time we visited over a year ago)
Mike
United States · Couple · November 2025
“Great place. Spacious and awesome place to host friends/family for Hocking Hills getaway.”
+Cabin-like atmosphere close to downtown Logan. Loft had a great barn vibe to it.
−Not really much to dislike. There were a couple bulbs that needed replacing and a small leak near the shower, but nothing major.
Shelby
United States · Couple · October 2025
“Wonderful Honeymoon Thanks to Rusty Lofts!”
+Great location - very walkable!
Denise
United States · Group of friends · August 2025
“Girls trip”
+Everything. This loft is gorgeous.. spacious, comfortable, close to everything, and everything we wanted. When we got there there was no hot water we sent a message and before we knew it it was fixed. They respond super quick to any issues. So nice. We loved everything.
Bradley
United States · Couple · June 2025
“Very good”
+Soft jazz playing on arrival, great decor.
−AC systems were confusing, one never turned on. Remote for bed tv did not work.