Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 39 reviews.
Matthew
United Kingdom · Couple · November 2026
“5 Stars. Highly recommend.”
+Great location. But Edradour is a wonderful, top quality flat. Nice decor, great feel and vibe and right in town. Loved it.
−Pricey, but I did book late. Nothing wrong with the stay.
Christopher
United States · Couple · October 2026
“Great - highly recommend if staying in St. Andrews!”
+Great location and perfect for 2 people (or could be 2 couples.
−All was good. Above a popular bar and with students in session could get some noise upstairs but nothing too distracting.
Dmitry
Canada · Solo · September 2026
+The best location in town, charming and cozy apartment.
Catherine
United Kingdom · Group of friends · August 2026
“We thoroughly enjoyed our stay. Would love to come back sometime”
+It felt very homely
−Nothing
Sabine
Germany · Group of friends · August 2026
+Great location and superb decoration
Alina
United States · Couple · August 2026
“Wonderful stay in St Andrews”
+We could not have picked a better location or a more comfortable apartment for our stay in St Andrews. Edradour is beautifully decorated, spacious, and feels truly luxurious, while still having the warmth and charm of a home away from home. The bedding was wonderful, and we especially loved the beautiful modern bathroom with its deep tub and heated floors. Even though it is located above Mollie Malone’s pub the apartment is private and very quiet. The location is unbeatable,just a five-minute walk to the Old Course and perfectly situated for enjoying everything St Andrews has to offer. We loved being able to walk around town and were close to some fantastic restaurants, including Haar and Dune. Be sure to try the new Amber restaurant as well,it’s a must! The hosts were wonderful and easy to reach, and the thoughtful welcome of wine and Scottish shortbread was such a lovely touch. We will definitely be returning to Edradour and would highly recommend it to anyone visiting St Andrews. We wouldn’t hesitate to stay here again!
Jan
United States · Couple · August 2026
“It is an inviting property but needs two significant changes before it becomes a practical accommodation.”
+Tastefully decorated. Very central location
−The main bathroom is a disaster. The Freeform shower immediately flooded the bathroom and into the hallway. It took 3 large bath towels to cleanup. A plumber arrived the next day but the drainage continued to cause a problem He said the system needs redesigning. I was able to take a bath after receiving from the housekeeper a slip mat. My husband couldn’t shower during our reserved time. Also other than a saved utube sports cable, the main tv was not operable. The housekeeper begged off trying to resolve it so we didn’t use it.
Shelley
United States · Solo · June 2026
+Great location, walkable to the Old Course. The de or was very personal and a curated pictorial of the history of Edradour. M We looked forward to spending time in the lovely living room. Munch on South street was a quick way to grab a breakfast sandwich in a hurry.
−Well, we .misjudged Molly Malones, the pub on the first floor as a place to eat dinner! Not unless you like toaster oven pizzas
Keith
Ireland · Couple · June 2026
“It’s so central, we were there to play golf and it was ideal.”
+Amazing facility. Very cool and very comfortable. The location is also amazing
−It was perfect!!
Sharon
United States · Couple · November 2025
“I would recommend this property (and have already) to anyone wanting a stylish but authentic place to stay in Scotland!”
+The apartment was large for the area and well-appointed. It was located in walking distance to most of the sights, shops, restaurants, grocery store, and bus station. We were able to find parking on the street in front of the apartment each time we ventured out. The apartment was clean and well-maintained. And the owners were easily accessible for questions. They even went above and beyond for an item that was left behind. Even though there is a pub located 2 floors beneath the apartment each, we were never really bothered by the noise (and we are fairly light sleepers).
−I usually like a few more towels for 4 people and more soaps and shampoos.