Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 60 reviews.
Tracey
Australia · Couple · July 2026
9.0“Wonderful location, great facilities, spotlessly clean and very charming.”
+Donnaberado was a gorgeous Tuscan escape. WE loved the clean, well equipped self contained apartment. WE loved our privacy too. Tucked away. The view was beautiful and the trees helped keep the apartment cool in summer. This was most needed as there is no air conditioner. It is always more special when you are welcomed to your place by a person. WE received a warm welcome and communication was excellent.
−We did not read all the details that there was no air-conditioner which would have made a big difference even if it were only in one room. This is a good lesson for anyone booking a place in the summer. I must not forget to mention that this town is so hilly. Filled with steep hills. Make sure you fit!
Greg
Australia · Couple · November 2025
8.0“Relaxing place to enjoy the village”
+Quiet and nice views
−Motor vehicle access
Paula
United States · Solo · November 2025
10.0“I am grateful for my time there.”
+It is my favorite spot to stay in Cortona: warm and bright and comfortable.
−If someone has mobility issues it is unlikely to be a good fit. It is a steep climb up the hill and there are stairs to reach the apartment. The street it is located on is intended only for small vehicles. For most people it is not a problem.
Domonique
United States · Couple · November 2025
10.0“Beautiful”
+Location and the size of the apartment
Baron
Taiwan · Family · October 2025
4.0“Caveat emptor”
+On my contract, a balcony was listed, but our apartment had neither a balcony nor a view. I explicitly rented this apartment for the view. We would not have booked this property if we had known there was no view. I gave the management and owner an opportunity to discuss this matter in a friendly way, but they lacked the ability or willingness to do so. I finally traded texts with the owner Marco and he seemed arrogant in my opinion. He claimed that the errant balcony listing was his mistake. Was it merely a mistake? I don't know. But, the promise of a view obviously brings in customers. That's most likely why a balcony is featured in the cover photo for these rentals (I believe there are three). Marco claimed I hadn't been careful enough and I should have been able to surmise the actual situation. Perhaps. But, to me, before booking, all of the information was taken out of context. To Marco, who is very familiar with his own property, all information is in context. He claimed something that he very clearly knows is not true. I decided to stay there despite my disappointment, because finding other accommodations would have been difficult. Believe me, I checked. Also, my wife isn't h
−The drive in, through old town Cortona, was challenging, and the old stone buildings seemed to interfer with the signal from Google maps. Also, parking near the property is limited. You may have to wait for a spot to become available. Not much was offered in the kitchen. No salt. Just two espresso pods for two people for three days. Generosity does not seem to be a strong point here.
Katherine
United States · Couple · September 2025
6.0“Great location but hard to get to.”
+The location was very good proximity to center. Be prepared to walk up a. Wet steep hill though to get back from center. Parking absolute nightmare and to get to property was very difficult by car. But pretty much all of Cortona roadways are difficult to maneuver through. People who own home were nice and helped guide us into area so we could park.
−Besides it saying balcony in ad… there’s none at all. There is a garden area that you cannot even see from home. Have to go outside and down stairs to get to. Small table with two chairs. Property very dark. Was left with only two towels for 5 days. No paper towels and no tissues provided. No true views from windows of home. Large trees block views. Only nice view from close to fence in garden area.
Richard
Germany · Couple · July 2026
8.0+Lage hervorragend
Luigi
Italy · Couple · June 2026
9.0+Posizione, strutture
Knut
Norway · Couple · June 2026
10.0+En gjemt perle. Rolig, men samtidig nært alt. Flott leilighet. Fantastisk utsikt fra hagen
Beatrice
Switzerland · Couple · June 2026
9.0“Jederzeit wieder!”
+Balkon mit Traumauusicht
−Küchenausstattung, nicht wirklich eingerichtet zum Kochen. Aber es hat viele Restaurants in Cortona:)