Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 120 reviews.
Debra
United Kingdom · Couple · October 2026
“Stunning apartment”
+Lovely clean comfortable apartment in the heart of Killin.Had everything we needed for our two day stay, was warm and decorated beautifully.Had great communication from the owners from beginning to end of booking. We would definitely book this place again when next in the area.
CarolAnn
United States · Solo · October 2026
“I would happily recommend staying in Craiglea Thistle.”
+Very comfortable little flat, perfect for me. Cute village with awesome waterfall. Parking space behind flat is great!
Keith
United Kingdom · Solo · October 2026
+Central, close to park for dog, parking to rear, clean tidy, well presented, everything you need, hosts keep you up to date on booking etc
Susan
United Kingdom · Couple · August 2026
“Great base for a couple nights away”
+Very clean and good quality furnishings. Bed very comfy. Everything we needed for couple nights away. Off street parking space. No extra payment to take the dog either.
−There is a small shared (with adjoining holiday let) front garden area with planters/flower pots and a bench which could, if allowed, possibly benefit from a slightly higher boundary feature/trellis separating garden from pavement and made a bit more ‘garden like’.
kirsten
United Kingdom · Couple · July 2026
“loved this apartment. It had everything we needed for a 2 night stay and was so clean and tidy - but cosy and welcoming”
+Modern. Cosy. Immaculately clean. Well equipped. Comfortable. Welcoming.
−Nothing
Billy
United Kingdom · Solo · June 2026
“Beautiful cottage in a great location in central location. I will return”
+Location is ideal the 4 dog friendly restaurants are all within a 5 to 10 minute walk. A large park is behind the cottage. Good having own private parking place off street. I didn't expect the hospitality tray so that was a bonus .
−I enjoyed my stay and will return. Only slight negative is I am used to a larger TV but that is splitting hairs.
john
United Kingdom · Couple · May 2026
“Excellent”
+All of it
−None of it
Snape
United Kingdom · Couple · April 2026
“Immaculate comfy apartment in central location.”
+Excellent central location, comfy immaculately clean apartment and lovely host.
−Nothing.
Jacqui
Australia · Couple · April 2026
“We loved Killin & Craiglea Thistle Cottage.”
+It was warm, friendly & excellent location. The Kitchen was so nice to have. Short walk to attractions, co-op,cafes & Killin Hotel.
−Extra tea bags would have been handy & a range of pillows would have been nice, all 4 were very soft but very minor issue.
RJ
United Kingdom · Couple · April 2026
“Central location, easy access to everything, lovely cozy property with parking, would stay again.”
+The property felt warm, cozy and a home from home very quickly. We were able to park right by the gate/property to unload/load and then park just behind the property in the allocated parking spot which was great. We didn't need to communicate with the hosts during our stay but the communication before and after was great. The location is beautiful, a park, lovely walks through the village, lovely scenery and views. A big Co op just around the corner, pubs, coffee shops, post office, charity shop and friendly staff. Comfortable kitchen/living space, lovely shower, comfy bedroom with hanging and drawer space. Everything made for a lovely, chilled, relaxing stay.