Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 11 reviews.
Fox
United Kingdom · Couple · November 2026
9.0“A super cute Cornish cottage Ina great location”
+Super cute cottage great location
−Nothing - all good
Kate
United Kingdom · Family · June 2026
8.0“All good!”
+Perfect for our needs
−No shower!
Stephen
Australia · Couple · June 2026
10.0+Very easy and clear instructions for picking up the key. Crabpot is a really atmospheric and traditional Newlyn cottage; it has a concrete floor which would be cold in winter, so bring slippers if you are staying there. Also, it has a steep and narrow staircase. We left our cases downstairs and moved the clothes and other things we needed upstairs. And because it's a traditional house it has a bath, but no shower, so be ready for nice relaxing baths! It was hot in the first few days of our stay (yes it can be hot in Cornwall), but because the cottage has doors on both sides, it's easy to air the cottage. Also, don't expect that a taxi can bring you to the door. The last 50 metres is walking on cobblestones however you try to do it, but that's part of the charm. A wonderful experience
MattCatt
United Kingdom · Couple · January 2026
10.0“Great cottage”
+Style, roomyness, warmth, ambience.
−No microwave , no dishcloths, no scourers
Gordon
United Kingdom · Couple · October 2025
3.0“Quaint cottage in great location. Cottage needs money spent on plumbing & electrics.”
+Great location in authentic Newlyn. Factor in parking cost when budgeting.
−Water leak. Reported but not fixed or actioned. Wet kitchen. Suspect wiring including one potentially dangerous diy extension. Cupboard with gas combination boiler damp & smelly. Rotten floor boards painted over. (Possibly from bathroom leak)
Bob
United Kingdom · Business trip · June 2025
8.0“We had a very pleasant stay and would recommend Crabpot Cottage to others”
+A very homely, clean and well decorated cottage
−The absence of a microwave; the uneven steps particularly upstairs (my wife needs to us a walking stick)
Amanda
United Kingdom · Business trip · March 2025
8.0“A wonderful week in Newlyn.”
+I liked the cottage. It was very characterful and comfortable. The wood burner and sitting room was warm and cosy. The bed was comfortable. I liked the bathroom with the seaside details and the deep, antique bath. Close to Newlyn village with food and artisan shops. Liked the Tolcarne Inn for a roast, the nearby cafe, antique shop and the cinema. The co op was very near for provisions and the sea bass, mackerel pate and prawns bought at the local fish market was outstanding !
−I didn’t like the fragrant diffuser. The duvet was too hot.
Jill
United Kingdom · Family · October 2024
7.0“Good”
+Good position. Nicely decorated.
−The bathroom door didn't close. The main bedroom window didn't open. In the small bedroom, the front of the under bed drawer is falling off. Bathroom - no soap dish or similar to use in the bath and no shelves to put toiletries. The only surface to put anything was the toilet!
Rowthorn
United Kingdom · Solo · September 2024
10.0“Super Cool Cottage”
+The location is great. So close to the Fish Market, beach and independent cafes and coffee shops plus the Co-Op so I didnt have to drive to get provisions! . Cottage itself super cool and a real treat to have a free standing bath. Very quiet too. The soft furnishings were sumptious and bed very comfortable.
−Nothing
Peter
Switzerland · Couple · August 2025
2.0“Ohne Komfort um jeden Preis”
+Zentral gelegen, nahe einem (teuren) öffentlichen Parkplatz und nahe Lebensmittel-Geschäft.
−Wer es gerne authentisch-primitiv mag, ist hier richtig: ohne Aussicht an wenig attraktiver Lage im alten Fischerhafen-Quartier, fleckig-fettiger Steinboden im Erdgeschoss, Küche ohne Geschirrspühler dafür mit mit alter abgenutzter und rostiger Spühle und mit einem unappentitlichem Holztisch, Badezimmer mit Badewanne ohne Brause zum Duschen, Badezimmer-Lavabo beschädigt, eines von 2 Schlafzimmern ohne Verdunkelungsmöglichkeit, unkomfortable Betten …… Der Retro-Look auf den Bildern ist Augenwischerei. Luxeriös ist hier nur der Preis!