Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 11 reviews.
Lynsey
Australia · Group of friends · January 2026
“An exceptional setting let down by unclear expectations and operational oversights.”
+We recently stayed at Circular Bay Beach House on Waiheke Island. The location itself is undeniably beautiful, peaceful, and very special. The natural surroundings and sense of remoteness are part of what makes the property unique, and we did enjoy the serenity and scenery during our stay. However, there were several important details that were not clearly communicated in the listing, which significantly impacted our expectations and experience. Firstly, the reservation was non-refundable at the time of booking, yet critical access information was only provided in a confirmation email a few days before the stay. The property is extremely remote and requires a true four-wheel drive vehicle to access comfortably. This was not clearly stated in the Booking.com description. We were fortunate to already have a suitable vehicle, but this could easily catch other guests out. Secondly, the listing indicated proximity to Mudbrick Estate, which led us to believe we were staying near the winery grounds with the ability to walk through vineyards to meals and tastings. In reality, the house is approximately 40 kilometres away, requiring a serious drive. This should be clearly stated in the list
−This meant our final paid hour of quiet enjoyment was disrupted, which was disappointing given the premium nature of the stay and the emphasis on peace and seclusion. Overall, the property itself is beautiful and we did enjoy many aspects of the stay. However, due to the lack of clarity in the listing, the remoteness logistics, privacy limitations, missing essential kitchenware, and the early morning maintenance disruption, we would not personally recommend this property to others unless these details are clearly understood in advance.
Katrina
New Zealand · Couple · January 2026
“Lux comfort in the most peaceful spot with stunning views”
+Beautiful location, clean, comfy beds and pillows. Really peaceful, spacious living area, great privacy & amazing views. This was our second stay in this house and would definitely return and recommend to others.
−The road out to house is quite narrow, steep and curvy in parts, would make sure we always travelled in daylight.
Joan
New Zealand · Family · September 2025
“Had a wonderful stay at the Circular Bay. The spot is priceless”
+Very private location, away from the main road and areas. Good white towel and they are soft and snow white.
−Only the main master room has curtain and upstairs top room has blinder, although it is very safe and private at the location.
“Stunning location and enjoyable stay!”
+Stunning location with a character-filled house. Private rocky beach. Lots of books and games to entertain. Owners happily accommodated a late checkout request. Well heated. We loved our two nights here! And hope to return one day. Waiheke really has something for everyone!
Donna
United States · Family · December 2023
“Exceptional”
+The location and the amenities were superior. The hosts thought of everything and our stay was extremely comfortable! We were returning visitors and would love to stay here whenever we visit Waiheke!!
Ziah
New Zealand · Group of friends · October 2023
“Pleasant”
+View was stunning!
−The Fan heater was not working, it was freezing cold in the downstairs room. No curtains and air conditioning in 2 of the rooms upstairs and there wasn’t enough toilet paper. Communication with host wasn’t good either. We didn’t get a reply back
Lucy
New Zealand · Family · May 2023
“Stunning & relaxing spot on a beautiful island!”
+Amazing location!!! Right on the water. Everything you could possibly need inside, beautiful decor and very comfortable.
−nothing. we loved it
Donna
United States · Family · May 2023
“Great facilities. Comfortable accommodation. everything was perfect!!”
+We loved the interior decor and the privacy
−We loved it completely
Radhika
India · Family · April 2023
“it was a perfect getaway.”
+Location was amazing, wine in the fridge was a great surprise and much appreciated
−lots of cockroaches, and spiders around/ inside the house. Property could be lot cleaner considering professional are involved in cleaning. There were spider webs around house which were easily accessible to clean. Dust was visible which could be cleaned easily after every guest.
Aleia
New Zealand · Family · April 2023
“Exceptional”