Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 34 reviews.
Saayah
United States · Group of friends · May 2026
1.0“We did Not stay in that home, we left within 10 minutes.”
+Nothing
−My dates were Dec 6-8, I got there on Saturday Dec 6th 2025 at 3:10 pm and left at 3:18 pm. It was horrible, Rodent droppings in kitchen under counter, holes under sink, and gaps on top of back of kitchen counter, furniture was horrible, both indoor and outdoor, nails exposed in inside kitchen window, and outside window was loose with gap in top. It was a mess, I even looked inside the hot water tank closet, it was damp and dirty. A cleaning crew (2people) was just walking in as I pulled up, oh and there was absolutely no parking. There were 2 other vehicles there from neighboring homes, who apparently Airbnb too. Huge disappointment, and a waste of my time. It Was so bad!!
Heather
United States · Group of friends · April 2026
10.0“Cozy house on a quiet street”
+Everything was fantastic. Easy to get to. Location wasn’t far from the places we wanted to visit. Clean. Beds were comfy! Water was hot!!!! Exactly what I was looking for!! Communication was seamless!!
Bouler
United States · Family · June 2025
8.0“Our weekend stay was very pleasant because the neighborhood was very peaceful.”
+The property was very cozy. It was, also, very close to the attractions and shops.
−The mattresses were very hard, so we could not sleep comfortably.
Jeanine
United States · Group of friends · May 2025
8.0“Very good”
+Location was great, street is very quiet loved that house was clean and comfortable outside needs a lot of tlc, power washing whole exterior would of made hanging on back porch more enjoyable...
Yunexis
United States · Group of friends · December 2024
10.0“"The stay was excellent, and I had a wonderful experience. The accommodations were comfortable”
Alysia
United States · Group of friends · December 2024
9.0“Superb”
+Cute comfy home.
−Safety issues in bathrooms: no nonskid mats and no grab bars for the low bathtub. We stayed during thanksgiving so we cooked but there were no casserole dishes, spatulas. Dish towels were not available. They are easy to wash instead we used excess paper towels not environmentally good. would be nice to add a full mirror to the front bedroom had to go in sisters room for dress check. Owner was out of country and wasnt offered a number or who to call locally to find remote for front bedroom tv so went all week without the ability to watch tv from my room. Thanksgiving
Deborah
United Kingdom · Group of friends · November 2024
8.0“Loved Lincolnville. Easy access to historic centre.”
+Loved the location. Inside furniture was great with a distinct retro feel.
−No kettle. Few wine glasses. Poor condition of the timber floor on the porch.
David
United States · Family · November 2024
6.0“Location was good but needs some updating on the security and window coverings to feel safe.”
+Location was ideal as it's a 15 minute walk to main town and 5 minutes to the winery and distillery. Facilities were very clean and parking was just out front.
−Window locks are broken and/or don't work which made it feel unsafe. Also the curtains in the front bedroom and living room are see through with no blinds so anyone walking or driving by can see right nin. The only room with black out curtains was the master which was nice but hard to sleep in the other room as the sun rises very early in November and the curtains don't block any light. Was also surprised when we paid the cleaning fee which was $250 when it's $180 on AirBNB. Definitely feels like the owner is trying to market discounts and then cover the discounted price through the increased cleaning fee. Also, expected with the high fee to not have to take the trash out, or trip the beds but that was expected when leaving.
Lisa
United States · Couple · October 2024
10.0“Fantastic day, highly recommend!”
+Cozy and warm house in the Lincolnville neighborhood, within driving distance of everything in St. Augustine and walkable to some popular bars and restaurants nearby. Super comfy beds, towels, and linens and everything you need to cook meals at home. I would highly recommend this property to anyone wanting a cozy respite in the St. Augustine area. Ashish was a dream to work with and was very kind and accommodating.☺️
Wendy
United Kingdom · Couple · October 2024
7.0“Well equipped, clean and comfortable inside - outside areas need some attention.”
+Well equipped on the inside
−Outside space was very grubby and we couldn’t use any of the furniture without having to really scrub it all . Had initial problem with curtains and door handles but host was quick to respond and eager to resolve.