Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 24 reviews.
Clive
Australia · Couple · June 2026
2.0“Lousy apartment with no keeping services. This unit we stay is managed by a differently n individual”
+This is not a hotel or service apartment. I am not happy that there is no housekeeping services provided and no washing machine and dryer in the apartment. Only 1 set of towel is being provided . Also only 1 set of key is being provided. This unit we stay in is managed by a different n individual landlord unlike the other units which were managed by a hotel group service Oak which provide better service . This discrepancy was not communicated and reveal to the clients before they book The unit
−Washing machine and dryer is not provided. No housekeeping services Only 1 towels are being provided for my long stay on 10 days . The toilet and bathroom is very small
R. Adriel
Netherlands · Solo · March 2026
1.0“Probably would have been fine if I didn't have to rely on customer service for anything.”
−I had asked for early check-in, which was granted, but the room was not ready when I arrived at the agreed-on time. And there was no power in the room. I left so the room could be cleaned, and returned but still no power. Customer service asked me to 'Please be patient' for several hours, and never once offered any consolation, only requested 'patience'. I had traveled 24+ hours from Europe, and my patience was maxed after several hours waiting for customer service to either fix the power issue, or relocate me; neither were ever offered, so I left the keys and found a room elsewhere. The location and room are probably great if you have no need to rely on the customer service, as they are incapable and inconsiderate.
Kriss
Poland · Solo · January 2026
1.0“Scammer company, No refund initiated since 14 days, Very dirty studio, Horrible air quality”
−AVOID WITH ALL MEANS !!! This is a criminal organization that cheats with everything , with money refund ! They have developed a scam messaging system that should fool you until you give up on your money refund. - SCAM WITH A PARTIAL REFUND. After 14 days refund still not even processed it internally. Everytime they write a about the refund transfer can take up to 7-14 days, but before the transfer is initiated they write they must approve it internally and it can take around 3 months until you give up on your refund (!!!). This is Third World scam, and not Australian quality. This scammer company must be checked and closed by the Consumer Affairs Victoria and the Victorian State Government soon. -Contradictory information: One agent writes the refund has only been initiated and should arrive depends on the bank account, another agent writes the opposite. All is just to fool you until you give up. - VERY DIRTY STUDIO BY ARRIVAL. Dust, oily hands fingerprints on all furniture. Pictures attached. Partial refund was agreed and after 14 days they write they still did not process it internally. - HORRIBLE AIR QUALITY. Not possible to open a window. It is a private studio in a hotel, tho
Georgia
Australia · Couple · January 2026
9.0“Pleasant stay!”
+Perfect location, especially for the Australian open! Room was huge and loved that there were cooking facilities and dishwasher.
−The shower wasn’t in the best condition and the bathroom was tiny. Also no oil/butter for cooking :(
Gill
Australia · Couple · January 2026
9.0“Lovely comforable compact appartment with room to move and relax after a long day out.”
+Location and comfort
−Nothing all was great except the toilet kept running but we worked out if we jiggled the button it would finally stop
Ron & Robyn
New Zealand · Couple · November 2025
9.0“nice spacious property”
+Central position when you worked out how to use the trams and the free inner city area
Alister
Australia · Solo · October 2025
8.0“Convenient and well priced.”
+Relatively central and close to Southern Cross Station. All the amenities worked well and having a functioning kitchen was a big plus. Good sized room with clean sheets and a comfortable bed. It did everything it needed to and was reasonably priced.
−Could have been cleaner and it felt like there were a few unnecessary 3rd party middle manager types involved which didn't seem to add anything to the process. Not a bad place to stay by any means through.
Mama Iri
Australia · Family · September 2025
8.0“Always a pleasure when visiting Melbourne. Choosing the right place to stay is very important to me.”
+I like the location of the property, very central to what we needed it for. The room itself was neat and tidy and spacious for what we needed it for and the length of time we were there for.
−I didn't like the fact there was no ramp to get up the second set of stairs to the lift area. I watched some people struggle with their luggage weighing at least 20kgs. Otherwise the inconvenience was going through hotel lobby to the otherside and using the disable lift from the food court, which was not very visible to use, and only operated during work hours. The wifi did not work in the room. I logged into MadeComfy guest portal and the chat bot was not answering my question. It also kept telling I had to wait until I paid in full and my ID was verified which it was. Slightly frustrated here.
Simon
Australia · Couple · August 2025
9.0“Comfortable, clean and convenient for town”
+It was comfortable for what we needed. Close to the free tram system to get about town. Couple of nice old pubs nearby. I would recommend this location and apartment to others. The keys could be collected and deposited 24/7 and this was only a short walk from the apartments main entrance.
−Cups and glasses were not easy to reach
Livinia
Australia · Couple · July 2025
10.0“Genuinely a great booking!”
+It was a great location, and it had seriously good facilities! Super clean, well-maintained etc. When looking at this place online, my partner and I thought it might have been a scam considering how good everything looked, but I can assure, it was a really good choice for us! Right near an IGA if you want to make food, which they have an oven, toaster, dishwasher etc. you can use for, but otherwise there's great food places nearby! Really appreciated how nearby it was to public transport too. And right across the street were some lovely historical buildings, which could be seen from a birdseye view in the room. Generally found the view from the room to be a very cool one. Also, I appreciated all the clear instructions in the app from the madecomfy people who manage the place, it made it very simple to check in/out.
−Some reviews mention a leaky shower, but at least in our experience, it wasn't leaky, it just got wet on the bathroom floor. I will say, the toilet would keep flushing unless you held down the button for around 20 seconds, but that's the only issue I can think of.