Reviews from guests who stayed at this hotel, shared by our hotel supplier. Score based on the latest 48 reviews.
Tiree
United Kingdom · Group of friends · November 2026
“Excellent”
+It was huge great space on living room and bedrooms spaced out and fab size nice and clean
−Nothing loved it
Agnieszka
Poland · Group of friends · October 2026
“Good choice for a short stay almost in the heart of Edinburgh. Best for people who know one another.”
+We absolutely liked the location of the apartment and the fact that it was warm, or rather very warm, inside (in autumn time, after the whole days spent outside it was a wanderful asset of the place). The space in the living room - massive, the staircase was quiet - nobody interupted others while walking up and downstairs. Everyone could take a shower without worrying about hot water shortage. Well-equipped kitchen - enough plates, cups/mugs, cutlery, working dishwasher.
−Wi-fi signal was non-existent in some rooms. It was difficult to sit around the dining table whose size was massive (positive), but too big for the space (negative). Our double bed was not comfortable enough - too soft in the middle. The fridge didn't look well-maintained and for 17 people it was a bit too small. The silicone grouting in the bathtub upstairs needs urgent exchange - it looks (and most probably is) mouldy. The sofas in the living room were a bit too soft - it was difficult to rise up.
Rok
Slovenia · Group of friends · September 2026
“Amazing place, top location”
Wilcox
United States · Family · September 2026
“Be prepared for stairs!”
+Great location and great for a large group!
−Nothing
Katherine
United States · Group of friends · September 2026
“So disappointing for a house with such potential”
+A house of this size is not easy to come by in such a close in location to the city center. There is plenty of space for a large group, and the key boxes made coming and going easy. Unfortunately the pros were greatly outshadowed by the cons.
−Unfortunately the house has been neglected and we ran into multiple issues throughout our stay that took time away from our vacation to resolve. We felt cheated, especially given we paid such inflated Fringe prices. - There are only 2 showers for a house that sleeps up to 20 people. We knew that when we booked, but once we arrive one bathroom had no hot water , then the host "fixed" it, and it had no cold water and only scaldingly hot water. The only other bathroom had a gaping hole in the ceiling above the shower, through which water from the other bathroom leaked through. - The wifi only worked in certain areas. - The house has a washer but no drying racks or clotheslines , and none were provided when requested. I had to find a hardware store, buy clothesline, and spend the first morning of our vacation finding places around the house to string up clotheslines. - One of the sofas is completely collapsed , you sink it a good foot when you sit., One of the beds sits at an angle, with the feet sloping down., Most of the mattresses sag or creak. - Only one, thin pillow per bed. - We had to request soap and hand towels in the bathrooms. - One bedroom was missing window coverings entir
Michael
United Kingdom · Group of friends · May 2026
“Brilliant!”
+The property has a really grand feel to it with excellent entertainment areas. For big groups the property is excellent and works out much more cost effective than hotels.
James
United Kingdom · Group of friends · March 2026
“Brilliant stay. Excellent house and great location. Host was very accommodating”
+The house is absolutely huge and has all the facilities you would need for a comfortable stay in Edinburgh. In an absolutely great location which is handy for getting around the town. The host was also very helpful, accommodating and quick to respond to all of the queries that we had about the property.
−Everything was great. No complaints at all.
D'Arcy
Ireland · Group of friends · January 2026
“Fantastic”
+The location and size of the living room were incredible. I would definitely return with friends
−There was a small issue with one of the ceilings above the shower leaking
Samuel
United Kingdom · Group of friends · January 2026
“Very good location.”
William
United Kingdom · Group of friends · January 2026
+very big and comfortable for a large group. host was very receptive.